Pirates general manager Neal Huntington rolled out yet another gem Sunday that will no doubt come back to haunt him at some point this season.
“The free agents have better backs of baseball cards,” Huntington said Sunday. “That might pacify some people in the short term, but really we’re out here to win games and we believe in a lot of these players."
Rough translation: The Pirates don’t need proven players because they will do much better with younger, less proven (cheaper) players. In reality, that’s nonsensical, but let’s roll with it. Say the Pirates have a good young core of players ready to burst out and prove everybody wrong. The young pitching staff has a chance for some young arms to work out. The same applies to third baseman Colin Moran, who may do well with a change of venue and a short right field porch. The one area with no hope is left field. The Pirates don’t have a left fielder, and none of the five players auditioning for the job is a legitimate option. We know because the back of their baseball cards tells us as much. Let’s break it down:
- Sean Rodriguez is a career super utility man. He is an excellent fielder at most positions in the infield, but he is only an average outfielder. He is also a career .230 hitter with an OPS of .686 (89 OPS+) and little power (one season of 13 or more homers). He is a perfect bench player, not an everyday player.
- Daniel Nava is at least actually an outfielder, albeit a very average fielding one who was signed off the scrap heap. Nava is a “professional hitter,” which is a nice way of saying he is a perfect option as a pinch hitter. He hits better than Rodriguez (.267 career hitter, OPS .737) but with very little power (29 career home runs in 1,977 plate appearances).
- Adam Frazier is probably the best option because he is the best hitter of the bunch, but he is also an extremely average fielding outfielder. His numbers at the plate are respectable (.283 BA, .347 OBP) but he has little power and his OPS+ (98) suggests he is a slightly below average hitter.
- Jordan Luplow, like Nava, is at least an outfielder. He is a rookie who the Pirates believe will be a decent hitter. He has also shown some power along the way. He is a below-average fielder with an average arm. Here is how he is graded as a prospect and he has “fourth outfielder/pinch hitter” written all over him.
- Jose Osuna is not a legitimate option here as an everyday player. He can’t be. If he is, this is a worse situation than it appears. His name has been thrown in the discussion, though. It isn’t pretty as he has an OPS+ of 79 and he hit .233 last season. He has a little power (emphasis on a little as his 162-game projection is 11 home runs) and he is a very average outfielder at best. Osuna is another player — see a theme developing here? — who screams “bench player.”
The Pirates can sell us all on the idea that their young pitching staff is loaded with good arms who will grow and succeed. They can sell us on the idea that Francisco Cervelli will return to 2015 form and stay healthy. They can even sell us on the idea that Moran is ready to prove he is a first-round talent. This five-man rotation or competition in left field is ridiculous. It’s the kind of nickel-and-dime move that irritates Pirates fans and sets the team up to be criticized.
The Pirates are reloading, so they were correct to move on from Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen. They were correct not to go out and spend money on free agents, allowing their younger players to gain experience and grow. There is no excuse, however, for not signing a left fielder with a back of the baseball card that suggests he can handle the position on a daily basis. The Pirates needed to address this position in the offseason and chose not to, and it has left them scrambling to find an answer that isn’t currently on its roster.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.