Clint Hurdle, like every manager at this point, is excited about his team. He is excited about the prospects of the season. He talked glowingly Wednesday about how the Pirates’ destiny isn’t predetermined and how every year produces surprising teams. He even went as far as to say that some day soon PNC Park will explode with celebration when the Pirates win the World Series.

“I’ve seen some wonderful things happen in this game and more often than not, nobody writes the script,” Hurdle said.

Spring is in the air, and hope springs eternal, but, unfortunately, at some point the season will begin, and that is when reality will hit. And the reality is, this team is not likely to shock the world and compete for anything.

In Las Vegas, the Pirates’ over/under on wins is 76½. That feels like an extremely easy under to bet, and at least one handicapper agrees with me.

Advertise with us

Start with this fact: The Pirates won only 75 games last year, then subtracted their best two players.

The pitching staff could be solid. The key word is could. That’s the problem — there are far too many “ifs” to realistically believe they will all come true. Every team has some questions. The best teams, though, aren’t relying on catching lightning in a bottle in order to have a good season.

Jameson Taillon has the stuff to be a No. 1 pitcher, maybe. Ivan Nova is a solid back of the rotation pitcher, maybe. Trevor Williams should be fine, but the Pirates need Tyler Glasnow, Chad Kuhl and/or Steven Brault to become something they have never shown themselves to be. There is hope that Joe Musgrove will become the fifth starter, though he proved in Houston he was far more effective in the bullpen than as a starter.

That pitching staff could be strong, but then again, I could win the lottery some day. It’s more likely the staff will still have more questions than answers by mid-season than the other way around. The same can be said about third base and left field, where the Pirates are trying to sell the idea of a super platoon at both spots. That was the plan at third base in December, when Neal Huntington said the Pirates had five viable options there. They have since brought in Colin Moran and will give him every opportunity to win the starting job. A lot has to go right in order for him to become an effective player.

The plan in left field seems to be to give every super utility player on the team a try. Jordan Luplow is actually an outfielder, but he will battle Sean Rodriguez, Adam Frazier, Jose Osuna and Daniel Nava for the job. There isn’t a saying that goes “if you have five left fielders, you have none” — but there should be.

Advertise with us

The Pirates will struggle to score runs. They don’t have much power beyond Josh Bell and don’t even have a lot of players with high on-base percentages. They will be average, if not worse, in the field.

If they aren’t in contention at the trade deadline (there is no reason to believe they will be), they will look to dump Nova, Josh Harrison, Francisco Cervelli and maybe even Jordy Mercer, making them a glorified Class team in the second half.

Add all of that up and the Pirates, despite Hurdle’s early optimism, are going to struggle for long stretches. There’s always hope, and teams do surprise, but this team. So, bet the under because it’s going to be a long year at PNC Park.