Roxette had a hit song on the “Pretty Woman” soundtrack that went: “It must have been love, but it’s over now, it must have been good, but we lost it somehow...”
This is how Pitt should view its rivalry with Penn State. It’s time for Pitt fans and some in the athletic department to stop trying so hard to forge a relationship that is no longer two-sided. It’s time for Pitt to stop acting like a scorned lover and understand it can and has done better without Penn State.
Pitt doesn’t need a rivalry with Penn State to survive and even thrive. The sooner Pitt realizes and accepts this, the better off it will be. It’s pathetic that every time Penn State adds a team to its schedule not named Pitt — like Monday, when the school announced its 2020 schedule — the Pitt faithful take it personally and act as if some crime has been committed.
All of the reasons we’re told Pitt needs to play Penn State are utter nonsense. Pitt has proved it can sell out its stadium against other teams. It has proved it can recruit at a high level, even within the state, without having Penn State on its schedule. It has proved it can play for conference titles without playing Penn State. Pitt did these things multiple times from 2001-2015, when Penn State wasn’t on the schedule. Dave Wannstedt averaged nine wins a season his last three seasons, had a 10-win season and twice played for the Big East championship. He never played against Penn State. Walt Harris won a Big East title and got to a BCS game in 2004 without playing Penn State. Wannstedt also had the best recruiting run of any coach at Pitt since the ’80s. His final five years, Pitt had more players drafted than the rest of the Big East combined.
Pitt’s biggest problem in football has nothing to do with Penn State. It has everything to do with Pitt’s ability to sabotage itself with regard to hiring and firing coaches. But Pitt has seemingly learned from the mess of the past 15 years and signed Pat Narduzzi to a nice, long extension. They gave him a raise, some assurances on facility upgrades and more money to attract/keep his assistant coaches. That’s how big-time programs operate, and Pitt is finally trying to act like a big-time program. That — not trying to artificially forge a rivalry with a team that doesn’t want it — is what gives the program hope for the future.
Pitt and Penn State, because their schedules are full, cannot play again until at least 2026. That means in a period of 25 seasons (2001-2025) Pitt and Penn State will have played only four times. That’s not a rivalry. Pitt will have played West Virginia 15 times and Notre Dame 16 times over that same period. Those are two teams most fans under the age of 35 can relate to, more than Penn State, as rivals.
Heather Lyke should pick up the phone, call West Virginia and work out a long-term home-and-home deal in football and basketball. The Backyard Brawl will scratch the itch of Pitt’s need to have a rival. Big Ten teams have only three non-conference games, and that’s why Penn State doesn’t want a a long-term home-and-home with anyone. They want to play some different teams and get exposure for recruiting in different areas.
Pitt needs to accept this and move on. It no longer needs to play Penn State for any reason other than that older fans want to see the game. Pitt can achieve everything it wants to achieve without ever playing Penn State again. The fact that there are still so many people at and around Pitt who don’t understand this and can’t move on is ridiculous.
Pitt needs to focus on building its football program into something that it can be proud of. It can happen, but it won’t happen as long as Pitt continues to believe it needs Penn State for some sort of validation.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.