Art Rooney II said a lot of things to the media this week that suggest he is either being a good company man or he didn’t pay attention to what went on with the Steelers this season. His words suggest that there is nothing wrong, nothing that needs to change and that many of the teams issues and controversies were overblown. He also suggested that the Steelers defense isn’t so bad, especially when you take a look at the state of defenses in the NFL these days.
That all sounds like company man stuff, to me, because Rooney is not completely blind, nor does he lack intelligence. He knows how badly his team underachieved this season, despite its glowing 13-3 record, but he’s just not going to throw his coaching staff under the bus publicly. He will step in this offseason to try to fix the things that ail the Steelers and will work hard to get it right. He is smart enough to know that the window to win another Super Bowl with Ben Roethlisberger at quarterback is closing and that the Steelers missed an opportunity this year.
How do I know he knows this? Well, actions speak louder than words, and the Steelers have slowly but surely begun to make some changes, starting with their defensive staff. Secondary coach Carnell Lake resigned his position, and defensive line coach John Mitchell was moved into a different role. They were replaced by coaching veteran Tom Bradley and former Steelers draft pick Karl Dunbar.
There needed to be a change on that side of the ball because something wasn’t working. Tomlin took over most of the defense and made many of the defensive calls in the second half of the season. If true, why is Keith Butler still here? Why has he not been shown the door or, ahem, “resigned” to pursue other opportunities? Tomlin has defensive roots, so perhaps that’s why he has kept Butler around. The defense is as much Tomlin’s baby as it is Butler’s, and if that side of the ball stinks, well, he has to take some of the blame.
That makes some sense, but what doesn’t make sense is why Joey Porter hasn’t “resigned” to pursue other avenues or been given another assignment. Mitchell’s unit was the best on the defense, and while it didn’t show up in the playoff loss to Jacksonville, it played a large role in a number of wins. Lake’s unit was a problem the past few seasons, but that was as much about a lack of talent as anything he was doing.
Porter’s unit, though, was the most disappointing on either side of the ball, given the talent he had to work with. He obviously mismanaged James Harrison, and Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt really didn’t progress this season. The position coach is responsible for his players’ development. Combine his lack of effectiveness as a coach with his controversies on and off the field, and it is a mystery as to why he still is on the staff. Actually, it isn’t that much of a mystery — he clearly has a friend in a high place.
Adding Bradley is a good move. He has 14 seasons of experience as a defensive coordinator and 15 as a defensive backs coach. He has experience drawing up defensive game plans, so he’ll be a valuable resource for Butler, who could use some help.
Some people bristle at Bradley’s hiring because of his connection to Penn State and the Jerry Sandusky scandal. That’s a dark time in Penn State history, but the idea that anyone who coached on the staff over those years should coach in Siberia for life is ridiculous. Bradley never was Sandusky’s supervisor, and it has been six years since Bradley resigned from his job at Penn State after not being named head coach.
Bradley will be a valuable asset with the Steelers, as will Dunbar, who has worked with Tomlin in the past and has a reputation as an excellent coach. It is always good to bring new blood and new ideas into a coaching staff, but the Steelers defensive staff especially needed a makeover and has got at least a partial one. That’s a good start, and it suggests Rooney understands what is at stake and is pushing the right buttons behind the scenes, even if his words suggest he thinks all is well with the Steelers.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.