This hasn’t been an offseason for Pirates fans to celebrate. The team seemingly has punted on 2018, doing nothing of significance to upgrade a roster that won 75 games last season. Worse, the Pirates traded away their best two players and have spent the past few weeks trying to convince everyone that the addition of Colin Moran has solved their problem at third base.

They did add Daniel Nava, so maybe Neal Huntington isn’t lying about trying to compete. ... OK, that’s going a step or two (or 10) too far, but Nava is proof the Pirates are trying to strengthen their bench.

Pirates fans are so angry this winter, they’re talking about boycotts and signing petitions to get Bob Nutting removed as owner.

Things have been rough, but it isn’t all bad news for the Pirates. This season likely will hinge on outfielders Gregory Polanco and Starling Marte, and, according to all reports, both have spent this offseason working out and working on their games. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Stephen J. Nesbitt wrote an excellent story from the Dominican Republic about Polanco’s workout regime. Marte has participated in these workouts, though not as religiously as Polanco, and he is also working on his skills in the Dominican Winter League.

Advertise with us

Polanco’s workouts are extremely important because he couldn’t stay healthy last season. He played in only 108 games due to injury. One his trips to the disabled list was due to an ankle injury, and four were a result of muscle strains. For most of the season, he never looked fully healthy.

He batted only .251 with a .305 on-base percentage, his on-base plus slugging (OPS) dropped to .695 (from .778 the year before) and his OPS+ was only 81. He also hit only 11 home runs and drove in only 35 runs, this despite the fact that he spent most of his season hitting in one of the prime positions to drive in runs. He also had another dreadful season of baserunning errors and struggled with consistency in the outfield, especially judging and tracking balls.

Read More

His workout regime in the Dominican seems to have helped his flexibility, core and agility. He should be leaner, stronger and more equipped to handle the wear and tear of a 162-game season. If that is the case, and he is healthier and doesn’t have nagging strains, he should play at a higher level.

Marte played in only 77 games last season, mostly because he was suspended 80 games for a performance-enhancing-drug violation. He wasn’t the same when he returned and hit only .275 (his lowest since his rookie season) with an on-base percentage of .333. He, like Polanco, continued to make egregious baserunning errors, and even his defense took a step back.

He went to winter ball, where he settled in until he was pulled due to a cut on his hand. In 30 games, he had a .333 on-base percentage and .438 slugging percentage while batting .277. He hit .444 with a .512 on-base percentage and 1.207 OPS in his final 10 games.

Advertise with us

Nobody thinks the Pirates will contend, but maybe they can hang around the wild-card race into August. They have no chance, however, if Polanco and Marte aren’t the star players they were touted to be. They have been somewhat enigmatic for most of their careers, but with Andrew McCutchen now in San Francisco, the Pirates are their team.

Now is their time to shine.