The Steelers and Patriots played a classic game Sunday night that ended in dramatic fashion. Two future Hall of Fame quarterbacks were on the field and both played at a high level. Multiple players who are the best at their positions made great plays. Both coaches navigated twists and turns.
It was one of the best games of the season and one of the better games in recent years.
Yet, in the aftermath of it, all anyone could talk about was a review of a touchdown and the subsequent overruling of it. That’s sad, but that’s what the NFL is becoming. Replay is at the center of too many pivotal moments.
The NFL isn’t alone. Major League Baseball and the NHL have expanded replay, so they suffer from the same problem.
With replay comes glitches to the system. But replay should be all or nothing. Make every play subject to replay or get rid of it all together.
The leagues need to use common sense. Replay was supposed to be a system that overcomes egregious errors made by referees on the field. Nothing more, nothing less. A fair question is how do you ensure that? How do you ensure that only the easiest mistakes to correct are fixed?
Read More
The first thing would be to get rid of the silly challenge system. Don’t put it in coaches’ hands at all. Make it simple: Every play is monitored by a review specialist in the league office. Every key play in football — turnovers and touchdowns — are subject to an automatic review. Every close play in baseball is, too, and every goal in the NHL is as well.
Then, have a clock put on the review specialist. If he/she can’t tell in, say, 25 seconds whether the call was correct, go with the official’s call on the field. It shouldn’t take more than that to spot egregious mistakes. If they need to look pixel by pixel, it isn’t an egregious mistake that needs to be fixed.
This system will never adopted because it makes too much sense, but it’s the way the replay system could be a good thing. I’m all for replay, but review every play and do it quickly. As these systems are, replay is bad because crucial replays have far too often dominated discussions after great games.
Sunday’s Patriots-Steelers game provided far too many highlights for people to be hung up on one play. If replay was used correctly, they’d have looked at that Jesse James play for 25-30 seconds and determined it was a touchdown because there was no egregious error that needed to be corrected.
That’s how replay was supposed to work and hopefully some day it becomes how it actually works.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.