PiratesFest has become an annual event where management explains how it believes the Pirates can win on the shoestring budget afforded them by owner Bob Nutting. Someone from management makes a ridiculous, usually intelligence-insulting and condescending comment designed to make sure everyone knows how wrong the team’s critics are.

Last year, it was president Frank Coonelly saying that it’s an “insult” that anyone would question the team’s commitment to winning. This year, it was Neal Huntington pointing out the percentage of payroll they pay to Andrew McCutchen.

“We already pay Andrew a significantly higher percentage of our payroll than the Penguins pay to Crosby,” Huntington told the crowd. “We'd love to pay the same percentage of our payroll to Andrew that the Steelers pay to Ben Roethlisberger — we'd also love for Andrew to [account for more than] half of our offense — and we're doing that. We already pay more.”

What does that mean? What does that have to do with the fact that the Pirates have yet to finish higher than 23rd in payroll?

Advertise with us

Everyone understands the constraints the Pirates operate within. Baseball economics are not fair and it’s tough for smaller market teams to compete. Nobody expects the Pirates to lose money. Yet, every year we’re lectured about how unrealistic fans are when they ask for a better product. Every year, we’re told a nonsensical comparison like McCutchen to Crosby and Roethlisberger. Every year, we must read between the lines to see the Pirates won’t add payroll and may even cut it.

This year’s coded message is the five-man platoon at third base. Huntington said, “Between [Adam] Frazier, [Josh] Harrison, [Max] Moroff, [David] Freese and Sean [Rodriguez], we believe that we can more than complement David and give him the down time that he needs to remain fresh and strong.”

Heck, why stop there?

Why not add Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco, Josh Bell, Andrew McCutchen and Jordy Mercer to the mix? And how can you forget Jose Osuna, who is playing some third base in winter ball?

The Pirates are about to get a windfall from Major League Baseball — they could receive as much as $50 million next year. From Bill Brink’s linked article:

Advertise with us

“And team president Frank Coonelly told fans at PiratesFest that the club’s share of Disney’s $1.58 billion investment in BAMTech — an arm of MLB Advanced Media, MLB’s interactive media and Internet company — will be available next year and be ‘reinvested into the club here.’ According to Sports Business Journal, each team could receive $50 million.”

That’s right, $50 million, and it will be “reinvested into the club” — they promise. Don’t hold your breath, though. Your definition of reinvesting in the club is not always the same as their definition. It could mean giving current players a contract extension, or it could mean putting money into Latin American scouting.

The Pirates aren’t likely to add anything significant and likely will have to decide between McCutchen and Harrison. One of those expensive commodities probably will have to be traded to create financial flexibility.

The Pirates aren’t that far away from being a legitimate contender if they hold onto McCutchen, Harrison and Gerrit Cole. Third base is where the Pirates should “reinvest” some of that windfall, but that’s unlikely. They’re good at making excuses and even better at making their fans feel stupid for asking questions. This isn’t the way most businesses operate. Then again, the Pirates are excellent at reminding us they aren’t like most businesses.