Mike Mitchell went on an epic rant Wednesday about the NFL’s system of discipline. He wasn’t the only one in the Steelers locker room, either, as Mike Pouncey, Cam Heyward, Ramon Foster and even Alejandro Villaneuva all weighed in on what they view is an unfair system of fining and suspending players for certain hits.

The discussion was built around Steelers rookie JuJu Smith-Schuster’s one-game suspension for a block on Vontaze Burfict Monday night. Smith-Schuster’s appeal was quickly rejected Tuesday, and the suspension was upheld by the NFL. Meanwhile, Bengals safety George IIoka was originally suspended for a game for his helmet-to-helmet hit on Antonio Brown, but his suspension was reduced to a fine.

This, coupled with Smith-Schuster’s suspension equaling that of Rob Gronkowksi for his attack on the Bills’ Tre’Davious White. It’s clear the two acts are not equal, but then again, comparing these kinds of plays is rather silly. They are completely different, but the NFL has made it clear it wants to make the game safer.

That fact is always lost in these rants every time a player is suspended or fined, and it doesn’t seem fair. At the heart of all of these disciplinary actions is the NFL wanting to make its game safer. The league doesn’t want to have a player die or become paralyzed on the field as a result of a hit that could have been prevented.

Advertise with us

The NFL’s system of justice feels random and sometimes unfair, so some of the Steelers are complaints are justified. Foster, who is the Steelers’ player rep to the NFLPA, offered the most pointed criticism of how inconsistent the system is.

“Super flawed, super flawed,’’ complained Foster. “There are so many errors in every situation, it’s ridiculous. There’s no common ground, there’s no justification in it. And if you say you’re going to suspend a guy for taunting, I thought taunting was a fine and not a suspension.”

He added: “They screwed it up. You say you’re concerned for player safety, but you had a guy who blatantly had a helmet to helmet and didn’t get suspended. You had a guy who just did a taunting and you try to justify it by suspending him. That’s not player safety.”

Foster is correct that the system is flawed and maybe there is a way to bring uniformity to the way the suspensions and fines are handed out. It isn’t that simple, though, because every play is different. Every player is also different — some are first-time offenders, and others are multiple-time offenders.

You can’t compare Gronkowski’s hit to Smith-Schuster’s hit because the situations were different, with one common thread: Gronkowski was suspended as a first-time offender, as was Smith-Schuster.

Advertise with us

Regardless, these kinds of arguments miss the point. The point is that the NFL is trying to make the game safer. Mitchell’s rant was epic, but it was also a bit ridiculous and off base.

“Just hand us all some flags and let us go out there and grab the flags off because we’re not playing football,” Mitchell said. “This is not [darn] football. When I was 6 years old watching Charles Woodson, Rod Woodson, Sean Taylor, the hitters, Jack Tatum. … That’s football. This isn’t football. This is a combat, contact sport. There are going to be injuries.”

The idea that the NFL is trying to turn the game into flag football is flat-out stupid. There are probably 120-130 plays per game. That means there are probably somewhere in the neighborhood of 100-110 tackles a game, and many more blocks. And out of them, maybe one or two draw a fine or suspension.

The physicality of the game is fine. There still are big hits, and football still is the most brutal sport on the planet. There is no way to make the game safe, per se, but the NFL should be applauded — not ripped — for trying to make it safer.

If the Steelers are upset that the system of fines and suspensions seems random and inconsistent, that’s a discussion worth having. But if you’re going to say the system and its goals are wrong, that’s ridiculous. Player safety is at the heart of it all, and that’s something every player should be on board with.