I remember the conversation like it happened yesterday.
“Well, does Pitt have a chance?”
“Not a chance. Not even if WVU has six turnovers and Pitt dresses Dan Marino in Pat Bostick’s uniform.”
That was the conversation I had with Rich Walsh of KDKA-TV (then WPXI) in the press box prior to 13-9. Ordinarily, a score alone doesn’t tell the story, but that is one that causes a certain — albeit opposite — reaction among Pitt and West Virginia fans.
Today, Dec. 1, is the 10-year anniversary of the greatest upset in Pitt football history. The Post-Gazette’s Brian Batko wrote about it this week from the perspective of Dave Wannstedt, former Pitt quarterback Pat Bostick and from some of the other Pitt players from that team.
I was the Pitt beat reporter and covered the game — and I still have no idea how Pitt won. This is the only game I ever walked into the building thinking one team had absolutely no chance of winning. I couldn’t come up with one scenario that had Pitt winning the game.
Read More
People forget just how bad that team was offensively. The Panthers struggled to complete a forward pass. Bostick was thrown into a tough situation. He was a freshman, left the team during training camp and didn’t return until right before the season. He was going to redshirt, but Bill Stull went down with a season-ending thumb injury in the opener against Eastern Michigan. That left coaches with two options — Kevan Smith, a baseball player (now plays for the White Sox) and an extreme project with little experience, or Bostick, a freshman who missed training camp.
It became apparent this was a problem in the third game against Michigan State, when the Panthers lost, 17-13. Pitt would have won that game had they just punted on first down of every series in the first half. Both Michigan State touchdowns were set up by interceptions — a pick-six and another that was returned inside the 5. The offensive staff figured out that day that the best bet to have any chance of scoring was scrapping the traditional use of a quarterback and going to the wildcat formation. In the second half, they direct-snapped the ball to LeSean McCoy almost every down, and he ended up rushing for 172 yards and nearly brought Pitt back to win.
McCoy was fantastic that season and really carried the offense, but with no threat of a passing game, he faced loaded defensive fronts every game. His season, given the limitations of the passing game, is the best by a Pitt player probably since Tony Dorsett in 1976. No disrespect to Larry Fitzgerald, Aaron Donald or Darrelle Revis, I always think of this 2007 season and say McCoy was the best player I covered.
Pitt’s offense was indeed awful and literally a one-man show, meanwhile West Virginia’s was the high-flying Pat White/Steve Slaton show. They had scored 45 points or more five times that year, including 66 against Connecticut the week before the Pitt game. In fact, the Mountaineers only had been held to less than 30 points one game — their lone loss to that point, 21-13, at USF.
It was a high-flying offense against an offense that couldn’t throw a forward pass. Pitt’s defense was improved from earlier in the season, but it seemed like it would have to pitch a virtual shutout to win. Against that offense, that wasn’t happening.
Even as the game wore on and Pitt made stop after stop, I kept telling Walsh, “This is the drive that White or Slaton does something special and crushes Pitt’s heart” — but it never happened. I talked to defensive coordinator Paul Rhoads a few days after that game, and he said they found on film that Pitt missed a total of only two tackles for an extra 6 yards. Given how fast and slippery the WVU skill players were, that is basically a perfect game.
The two lasting images I’ll always have are Big East commissioner Michael Tranghese with a blank stare like someone stole his dog and ecstatic Pitt lineman Mike McGlynn in the postgame talking about shocking the world. This game wasn’t in a vacuum, either. It had a lot of short- and long-term effects on college football. The two obvious ones are that it put LSU into the national championship instead of WVU, and it opened the door for Rich Rodriguez to leave and take the Michigan job.
I’ve covered thousands of games in my career and attended many more as a fan. Most of them run together, but a few are more memorable. Like everyone involved, this game will always be the most memorable for many reasons beyond the score.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.