Matt Murray’s injury in the second period of the Penguins’ win over the Flyers on Monday felt a lot like winning the battle while losing the war. Murray’s injury may or may not be significant, but the Penguins’ goaltending depth is now under the spotlight.

An injury to any player is never a positive thing, but this one could be a blessing in disguise because of when it took place in the context of the regular season.

The Penguins need to figure out if Tristan Jarry can be a reliable backup and win big games in the playoffs if called upon. He has appeared in only five NHL games, so he has a lot to prove. Mike Sullivan likes his potential, but his body of work is way too small to determine if he can handle the job on a regular basis.

It is early enough, though, that the Penguins can ride Jarry until Murray gets back and see where he takes them. If he can’t get the job done, the Penguins have time to make a move to shore up the backup position before the trade deadline. If he proves capable of handling the goaltending duties for an extended period, it would give the Penguins a viable option if Murray got hurt in the playoffs.

Advertise with us

Goaltending depth hasn’t been in question in recent years because the Penguins had Marc-Andre Fleury to rotate with Murray. And the Penguins likely wouldn’t have won either of the Stanley Cups in the past two seasons without both goaltenders.

Fleury was hurt just before the playoffs two seasons ago and Murray stepped in and led them to the Stanley Cup. Last season Murray went down just before Game 1 of the first round, and Fleury stepped in and led the Penguins to wins in the first two rounds. Fleury handed the duties back to Murray during the Eastern Conference final against Ottawa, but the Penguins don’t get that far without him.

That was a luxury the Penguins could no longer afford, and they exposed Fleury to the Vegas Golden Knights in the expansion draft.

It is not helpful to speculate as to how long Murray will be out, though it does seem as if he will miss a few games. That will provide valuable experience for Jarry and give Sullivan and his staff a real chance to evaluate him.

There is no doubt the Penguins will rally around Jarry, and he has proven to be a competent goaltender in his limited NHL action. The Penguins are 2-0-2 in the four games Jarry has played this season and he has a 2.88 goals against average. The Penguins seem to have a lot of faith in Jarry, too, because of his steely demeanor.

Advertise with us

“He’s so calm back there,” Bryan Rust said of Jarry. “He’s played really well when he’s been in there. If he goes in the net for an extended period of time, we have confidence in him.”

Jarry said he is ready for any challenge, and he also has faith in the players in front of him and believes the Penguins will all step up in Murray’s absence. He was spectacular Saturday in the Penguins’ 5-2 win over the high-flying Tampa Bay Lightning. He faced 35 shots and made 33 saves. And he also set the tone for the game early when he kept the Lightning from scoring during a four-minute power play.

Sullivan pointed to the Tampa game as proof Jarry is capable of playing at a high level and giving the Penguins a chance to win. He said the Penguins are in good hands with him in goal, and he will get an opportunity now to prove it.

“As far as Tristan’s concerned, we believe he’s a solid goalie,” Sullivan said. “I think the game he played against Tampa was the perfect indication of what he’s capable of.”

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com