Andrew McCutchen was the centerpiece of the Pirates’ revival from 2013-15 and is one of the best players in franchise history. His time with the Pirates is coming to an end, though, and that means the team is in search of another superstar to build around.
They don’t have to look too far; they already have one on the roster in first baseman Josh Bell. He has a chance to be the franchise’s next McCutchen, and that’s high praise for a player who just completed his first season.
Bell finished third in the National League Rookie of the Year voting; he should’ve been second, behind Dodgers star Cody Bellinger.
The amazing thing is that not only did some voters have someone other than Bell second on their ballot, 18 of 30 left him off their ballot all together. That tells me 18 people voting for these awards aren’t smart enough to have the privilege.
Bell was second among rookies in home runs (26), RBIs (90), total bases (256) and extra base hits (58). He led all rookies in hits (140) and walks (66) and appeared in more games (159) than any other rookie, too. His 26 home runs are the most by a switch-hitting rookie in the history of baseball.
And yet, there were 18 of 30 voters who left him off their ballot.
Read More
Bell’s career trajectory is similar to McCutchen’s, although it took him a little longer to get to the majors. The Pirates used the 11th pick of the 2005 draft to select McCutchen. Four years later he became the Pirates starting center fielder and finished fourth in the NL Rookie of the Year voting in 2009.
Bell was a second-round pick, and he is coming off a stellar rookie season. The Pirates hope he can develop into the player that McCutchen — a five-time All-Star, four-time Silver Slugger award winner and the 2013 NL MVP — was. McCutchen was the face of the franchise for nine seasons, but his skills have diminished and his time with the Pirates is coming to an end.
He has handed that baton to Bell, and he should because it is Bell’s time to shine. He is the team’s future, he represents hope and he gives them a middle-of-the-order-type hitter to build a lineup around for the next seven or eight years.
Perhaps Bell is a one-year wonder, but there is nothing he did this year that would indicate he’s a fluke. His talent and work ethic is obvious, and his desire to learn and improve has often been lauded by Clint Hurdle and Neal Huntington.
The most clear example of this is the way he has developed as a first baseman. He was a disaster in the field in the minors, and there was plenty of talk that his best position would be in the American League as a designated hitter. Hurdle spent much of the first part of the season using a defensive replacement for him late in close games. Bell steadily improved, though, and proved he was a reliable enough glove to finish games.
Bell isn’t Keith Hernandez down there at first, but he has made himself into a more than functional defensive first baseman. That is miles away from where he was coming out of spring training, and given his work ethic, he only figures to improve.
Bell has big shoes to fill, though, as McCutchen certainly checked all the boxes. He is a class act both on and off the field, he is generous with his time and involved in countless charitable and community projects. Bell seems to have a lot of those characteristics, too, and has already become a fan and clubhouse favorite.
The Pirates weren’t able to finish the job and build a World Series winner around McCutchen, and that’s a shame because he deserved a chance to play in one. They have a chance to get it right, though, with a team built around Bell, and it is up to them not to squander the opportunity.
Bell, like McCutchen, is the kind of player championship teams are built around. The Pirates are lucky to have him.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.