The NFL fully understands if its product suffers, so will the demand for it.
That’s why it’s baffling anybody would oppose fines for hits that cross the line. The NFL’s top asset is its players and the league should do everything in its power to protect them. That’s especially true when it comes to quarterbacks. Offense sells tickets, and for the most part, quarterback play dictates offense. There is already a shortage of good quarterbacks in the NFL. Bad or below average quarterbacks lead to offenses that produce ugly, awful football games.
When a premier quarterback (such as Aaron Rodgers) goes down, the NFL loses one of its main attractions. The Packers are scheduled to be on prime-time TV three more times this season, and fans won’t flock to the TV to watch Brett Hundley.
Mike Mitchell absolutely deserved to be fined $48,620 for his hit on Alex Smith on Sunday. It was a dirty hit that could have ended Smith’s season, or, perhaps, his career. That kind of low hit — as well as helmet-to-helmet hits, hits on defenseless receivers and any hit to the head — have no place in football.
“I’m not a dirty player, I’m not out here trying to take his legs out,” said Mitchell, who will appeal the fine. “It’s just one of those things you don’t want to see in a football game. So unfortunate that it happened because it ended up flipping momentum on the field in a significant way. We were in dominant control of that football game, and really before that.”
Smith, of course, had a much different interpretation of the play.
Read More
“I thought it was pretty late,” Smith said. “I mean, when you get hit in the back of your knee like that, I didn’t understand how that happened. Certainly, guys falling, rushing the quarterback, I get hit when it’s happening from the front and guys are trying hard. That one to me just seemed so weird to get hit that low coming from behind.”
To Mitchell, any of his teammates or Steelers fans who want to defend that hit: Just stop. There is no defense — everything about it was dirty. Regardless of whether he was pushed, the result of the play was Smith being taken out from behind below his knee.
This isn’t the first time Mitchell has been fined for a bad hit or drawn a dumb penalty. Mitchell’s history is why he has very little credibility and why his fine was so steep. According to this ESPN report, part of Mitchell’s fine (between $9,115 and $18,231) was because he also grabbed Smith’s facemask on the same play.
Perhaps Mitchell deserves the benefit of the doubt that he wasn’t trying to hurt Smith. That’s believable, but it’s also not relevant. The hit was dangerous, so he absolutely needed to be fined.
Some old-school football fans and former players decry attempts to make the game safer. They hate roughness penalties, rules to protect quarterbacks and the system of fines. They claim these rules are making football soft.
That’s silly.
Football still is the most physical game, and NFL games still feature plenty of full-speed impact every single Sunday. There are plenty of big hits, and defenders can still be extremely physical when they sack quarterbacks.
The difference is that players have had to learn how to tackle properly to avoid drawing penalties and fines. In general, the target they shoot for is below the neck and above the knees. They can hit that target as hard they want, as long as they don’t lead with the crown of their helmet.
There isn’t a lack of physical play in the NFL, and players aren’t being coddled. They’re being protected, which should be a goal that is celebrated — not jeered.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.