Andrew McCutchen may have played his final game at PNC Park as a member of the Pirates. If he has, the Pirates should be forever grateful because he was a huge piece of their rebirth, as Post-Gazette columnist Joe Starkey articulated in this wonderful column.
McCutchen is one of the most important players in Pirates history. He’s also one of the best, but there have been better. In terms of his value to the franchise, though, there aren’t many that were more vital to the team’s success than McCutchen has been. He put the entire franchise on his back and helped carry it out of a 20-year funk.
It would be a wonderful, feel-good story if McCutchen signed one more long-term contract with the Pirates and finished his career with the franchise. If ever there was a player that the Pirates should work to keep around, it’s him. The harsh reality, though, is the Pirates can’t operate in sentiment or sign players for any reason other than finances. The Pirates have one more club option on McCutchen, and they should exercise it and then move on.
It sounds harsh, but the Pirates are in a tough position. There isn’t a way for his time to end here that won’t be messy, but it has to happen. There isn’t a legitimate contract the Pirates could — or would — offer McCutchen that would make sense for both sides. McCutchen already gave the Pirates a hometown discount once (probably costing himself about $20 million), and he shouldn’t be expected to take a second one.
McCutchen’s skills have diminished some since his MVP days but he is still one of the best outfielders in the National League. It’s hard to know exactly what his market value is at this point, but there are probably some good guidelines based on what other players similar to him has received.
Jacoby Ellsbury is in the fourth year of a 7-year, $153 million contact with the Yankees. That is probably about what McCutchen could be worth, especially considering he is about the same age now as Ellsbury was when he signed that deal. That doesn’t mean that is what McCutchen will command, it’s just a guide. That is a lot of money, and unless Seven Springs suddenly has a windfall, there is no chance the Pirates can offer him a deal anywhere close to that. And they shouldn’t, actually. That would be the kind of contract that would hamstring the Pirates for a lot of years and could ensure they go through another extended period of losing. Think back to Jason Kendall’s contract and how much of an albatross that was for pretty much the duration of it. That deal made it very difficult for the Pirates to sign other players and forced them to shed payroll, as opposed to adding it.
Read More
If Ellsbury’s contract is a guide, how far below that would McCutchen have to go in order to make it work? Four years, $80 million? Five years, $90 million? Even deals that look like that wouldn’t make sense for the Pirates and really wouldn’t make sense for McCutchen as this next contract is his final opportunity to break the bank.
The Pirates’ best course would be to exercise his option for next season ($14.5 million) and hope he carries them to the playoffs one more time. The team is set up to win next year (if they make a few adjustments to the roster), but without McCutchen, they’d have one more huge hole to fill. The Pirates would then have to part ways with McCutchen and hope that Austin Meadows is ready to become a starting outfielder.
McCutchen has had a great run here, but it has to come to an end. Hopefully that end isn’t until after next season because that means the Pirates gave themselves the best chance to win next season.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.