The Pirates will finish with a losing record for the second year in a row and are probably another two seasons away from a playoff appearance. That could arrive next season, but given the Pirates’ youth, they aren’t likely to return to contention until 2019.

That’s why they should to commit to Elias Diaz as their starting catcher for 2018. That won’t happen unless they move Francisco Cervelli, and frankly, it isn’t realistic to think any team is going to take that horrendous contract off the Pirates’ hands. Cervelli is owed $22 million over the next two years — the cynic would say that’s $1 million for every game he will be healthy.

If the Pirates are interested in building another team with a three- or four-year window, they need to make baseball — not money — decisions next season. They need to figure out what they have and what they need so there’s a complete roster waiting for their young pitching staff in 2019.

We already know Cervelli is an often-injured, light-hitting catcher who spun a career year into one of the worst contracts general manager Neal Huntington has on his resume. We don’t know exactly what Diaz is, and given he is five years younger than Cervelli, the Pirates need to find out.

Advertise with us

Diaz hasn’t exactly stayed healthy, either, which is one reason his promotion to the majors took longer than the organization had hoped. He also hasn’t hit consistently, holding a .242 batting average with only one home run.

There is clearly risk in making Diaz the starter. He’ll have only 45 career starts by the end of this season, and he needs to prove he can hit and stay healthy. To see what they have in Diaz, the Pirates should plan for him to catch 120 games next season, and Cervelli will get the other 42. If Diaz can’t handle it, the Pirates still will have Cervelli to fall back on, and at that point they will at least know Diaz is not capable of being their starting catcher of the future.

Clint Hurdle said Monday that Diaz has benefited from starting a lot of games recently.

“[Diaz] is improving,” Hurdle said. “He has shown growth that comes with confidence and playing time. The arm, the transfer is getting shorter and quicker, the arm strength is there, more reps with the pitchers, more reps with the bullpen guys — one of the best things that will happen for him this month of September is his playing time and the experience he is able to gain.”

Hurdle said he is growing more comfortable handling pitchers and calling pitches and the Pirates want to see him continue that progress in six weeks of winter ball.

Advertise with us

“There is so much he’s learned, it has been very, very good,” Hurdle said. “The game was moving much quicker for him two weeks ago than it is now. He’s been able to slow the game down. We like what we see and we really believe we will continue to see more of it. He’s been healthy this year so that has worked out well.”

Diaz may or may not be the catcher of the future. He may or may not be able to play every day and stay healthy for an entire season. He also may or may not be able to hit well enough to merit a job as a starting catcher.

All of those questions have yet to be answered, and the only way they will be is if the Pirates commit to making him the starter in 2018.