Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. This feature will run each Wednesday, so you have a whole week to submit questions.

Let’s get started:

Chris Boehme, @cboehme2: If you had to choose one long-term deal, would you sign Andrew McCutchen or Gerrit Cole?

Zeise: I’d work on getting an extension done for McCutchen first. I don’t think a long-term deal with Gerrit Cole is realistic for the Pirates given his agent (Scott Boras) and what they will be looking for in a contract. I also think a long-term deal for a pitcher has a lot more risk than a position player and the Pirates can’t take high-priced gambles like that. McCutchen may be more realistic just because I think his preference would be to stay. The Pirates should offer him something like a 4-year, $72 million deal that starts next season. That’s about $18 million per year average. I don’t know if he’d take it because there will be bigger offers on the table but that is a contract he’d at least have to consider.

Advertise with us
Pirates bench coach Tom Prince (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Jay-Rod, @jaredsweeney: Will we [the Pirates] look inside or outside the organization for a manager next year?

Zeise: Clint Hurdle is likely going to be the manager next season. However, if he is fired or leaves on his own, there are two internal options that would be at the top of the list. Tom Prince and Joey Cora are both manager material, and one of them would almost assuredly be the Pirates manager if they need one next season.

James Franklin (Antonella Crescimbeni / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Ryan Clark, @rcclark1906: With James Franklin new extensions, will Pitt ever get to where Penn State is. I feel like they had their chance with PSU being down.

Zeise: The reality is Pitt and Penn State played last year, and Pitt won so how far “behind Penn State” could Pitt really be? The two programs are different, play in different leagues and frankly don’t even recruit that many of the same players anymore. Pitt needs to worry more about catching up with Clemson, Louisville and Florida State and keeping up with Virginia Tech and Miami than Penn State. Pitt versus Penn State is a great rivalry, but the two schools and programs aren’t really all that similar, so these comparisons people continue to try and make between them are silly.

Colin Kaepernick (Thearon W. Henderson / Getty Images)

Jon Tabay, @jctnj13: Paul, now that many players our not standing for the anthem, does that lesson the stigmatism on Kaepernick?

Advertise with us

Zeise: No. There are three groups of people with regards to Kaepernick, and they don’t seem to be open to changing their stances. One group thinks he is a martyr and they think he is owed something by the NFL. Another group hates everything about him and think he should be banished to some third-world country because he isn’t a real American. And then there are those who wish Kaepernick and the loudest people on both sides of the issue would just go away. The fact that more players are choosing that route in support of Kaernick will only fuel all three groups to dig in their heels on the issue even more.

Penn State's Saquon Barkley (Associated Press file photo)

Harold Zag, Johnstown: Is Penn State a legitimate National Championship contender?

Zeise: Yes, Penn State is a legitimate national championship contender. The Nittany Lions are the defending Big Ten champions and should be even better this year. There is no question they could win the Big Ten again this year and the Big Ten champion is always in the discussion for a playoff spot. Do I think Penn State WILL win the national championship? No. Penn State will have a great season but I think Ohio State will win the Big Ten and be the conference’s playoff participant.

Clint Hurdle (Associated Press file photo)

Sam Schilling: One of my main issues with Clint Hurdle is his frequent double switches. There have been numerous times during his tenure that he has done this in games that have gone to extra innings where he removed one of his best bats out of the lineup. What are your thoughts?

Zeise: Hurdle likes to keep all of his players engaged. He has an especially soft spot for bench players. He likes to give bench players a lot of opportunities to play. It often looks like he is over-managing, mostly because he is. Hurdle is a really good manager, but his need to tinker with the lineup all the time is annoying. The constant lineup changes and desire to give players like John Jaso starts makes it really difficult for anyone beyond the stars to settle into a role they are comfortable with.

Advertise with us
Josh Dobbs (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Jamie Barnhart: If the Steelers signed Colin Kaepernick, who do they cut on Sept. 2nd in addition to Houston? Dobbs or Jones?

Zeise: They could cut Dobbs and hope he doesn’t get claimed by anyone else. Then they could sign him back to the practice squad and keep Jones, Kaepernick and Roethlisberger on the active roster.