Clint Hurdle hasn’t had his best season as a manager. One could argue he has managed the Pirates out of a few wins this season and at times has put together lineups that didn’t seem to make a lot of sense.
His love of bench players such as John Jaso and Sean Rodriguez has clouded his judgement at times. Those two shouldn’t start nearly as many games as they do. And the idea that Jaso is a defensive replacement (as he was for Josh Bell for much of the first two months of the season) for anyone is laughable.
Monday against the Dodgers, Hurdle left Gerrit Cole in the game too long and it cost the Pirates the game. Cole was strong through six innings but ran into trouble in the 7th. Hurdle stuck with him even though it was clear he was running out of steam and Curtis Granderson hit one of his pitches out of the park for a grandslam.
Hurdle was deservedly criticized for that decision. He has also been criticized for his frequent lineup changes and double switches as well. All of those criticisms have some validity to them but Hurdle has proven he can push the right buttons to get a team to the playoffs.
There is actually a growing sentiment in this town among fans and media members that it is time for Hurdle to go. They think he has taken this team as far as he is capable and it is time for a fresh voice in the clubhouse. It isn’t surprising -— when things go poorly, it is usually the coach or manager who takes the fall.
The idea that Hurdle is the problem with this team, though, is 100 percent ridiculous. Hurdle is still one of the best things this team has going for it, and the Pirates should pray he stays around for a few more years. He isn’t a strategy genius, but his players love to play for him and he has managed a sinking ship as well as anyone could.
Read More
This is not Hurdle’s mess, and the Pirates failures of the past two seasons are not his fault. It would be unfair to make Hurdle the fall guy for this team; this roster just isn’t good enough.
Earl Weaver, Bobby Cox, Davey Johnson, Joe Torre, Tony LaRussa — name whomever you think is the greatest baseball manager — would not have this team any closer to first place than Hurdle. In fact, some of those managers probably would have the Pirates in worse shape because they wouldn’t be as creative as Hurdle has been.
In essence, Hurdle has been asked to make chicken soup out of ... well, you know.
Repeat after me : Hurdle is not the problem. Hurdle is a part of the solution, but he has been given an impossible task.
The team he manages is not good enough. It wasn’t good enough at the start of the season. It wasn’t good enough in June. It wasn’t good enough after the trade deadline.
Hurdle has been short-handed far too often this season both on the bench and in the bullpen.
Take the situation Monday with Cole. Hurdle said he was trying to get through the 7th with Cole because the Pirates bullpen was down three relievers. He said he had faith in Cole to get out of the situation, but that was just a manager taking the heat for the front office. There is no way Hurdle would have left Cole in the game long enough to give up the grand slam if he had a full bullpen at his disposal.
Early in the season Hurdle, was asked to win games with a cavalcade of Class AAA players lining his bench. The team has always been one key injury away from disaster because there is never a margin for error.
Hurdle isn’t perfect, but he deserves to be praised for his work. And he deserves a contract extension.
The owner has failed the front office and in turn the front office has failed Hurdle. It isn’t his fault this season has been such a disappointment, and he shouldn’t have to take the fall for it, either.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.