Mike Tomlin’s decision to hire Todd Haley as Steelers offensive coordinator in 2012 was not popular. Haley had just been fired by the Chiefs. He was branded as not being liked by players because of his fiery demeanor and public clashes with some of the Chiefs’ best players.

Haley’s hiring was viewed as favor by the Rooneys to Haley’s father, Dick, a Steelers director of player personnel in the 1970s and ’80s. Todd Haley’s competence has been questioned because he played golf in college, not football. All of those criticisms may have had some degree of truth to them, but none was fair. Dick’s connections may have helped Todd Haley get into the profession, but Todd worked his way up to his current position. He has earned his stripes and along the way learned from some of the NFL’s greatest coaches.

Haley and his play-calling aren’t popular among some Steelers fans but those fans are misguided. Haley has been one of the Steelers’ best assets over the past five seasons and has far exceeded his expectations. He is one of the top reasons the Steelers have been Super Bowl contenders the last two years and one of the top reasons to be optimistic about their chances this season.

Bruce Arians was fired in large part because he was too pass-happy, and as a result Ben Roethlisberger was getting hit and sacked way too many times. Haley has improved the Steelers in both areas. Roethlisberger was sacked 50 times in 2009 but only a combined 37 times in 2015 and ’16. Roethlisberger was sacked an average of 47.3 times the four years prior to Haley’s arrival but only an average of 28.4 times in Haley’s five seasons.

Advertise with us

The Steelers’ run game under Haley has been dominant at times. The final nine games of last season, Le’Veon Bell averaged 146 yards per carry and the Steelers had more rushing yards over that span than any other team in the NFL.

The Steelers have also had three of their most productive offensive seasons in franchise history the last three years. Since the NFL regular season expanded to 16 games in 1978 season, the Steelers have scored 399 or more points only five times. Three of those five seasons came under Haley’s watch.

They scored 416 points in 1979 and 407 in 1995 and those were the only two Steelers teams to score 400+ points before Haley arrived. The Steelers were a missed extra point away last season (they finished with 399 points) from scoring 400 or more points for the third consecutive season.

Haley’s offenses have benefited from the Steelers improved offensive line. The offensive line has also benefited from Haley’s blocking schemes and his commitment to give them help with the use of tight ends and fullbacks. In Arians’ offense, the offensive line spent way too many plays backing up in pass blocking instead of plowing ahead and imposing their will in the run game.

Haley’s philosophy is perhaps his greatest strength as he isn’t married to a system. He instead tries to plan for each opponent and that has meant the offense is never the same from week to week.

Advertise with us

“Whoever the opponent is we’re going do what gives us the best chance to score points and score more points,” Haley said last week. “When you look back at last season it’s easy to say we threw it too much here or there. At the same time, we’re going to go into games with an attack plan. Sometimes it might be running a lot and sometimes it might be throwing a lot.”

Haley said that the Steelers don’t have an elaborate offense. He describes his playbook as “scaled down,” and the reason is because he focuses in on only the things the Steelers do well.

That’s a sign of a coach who understands that his top job is to find a system that fits the personnel and not the other way around. Haley knows what the Steelers do well and he doesn’t ask them to do anything they can’t do.

The Steelers’ lack of scoring in playoff losses the past three seasons have obviously been a sticking point but they have been hampered by injuries to some of their most important players. However, they had Roethlisberger, Bell and Antonio Brown all healthy for the first time in a playoff game last season against the Dolphins. In that game they scored 30 points, Bell rushed for a franchise postseason record of 167 yards, Brown had 124 yards receiving and Roethlisberger threw two touchdowns.

Haley won’t win many popularity contests because he isn’t warm and fuzzy. He may not be popular because some people believe he has “shackled” Roethlisberger and his offenses are dull and lack imagination at times. Those views are becoming harder and harder to defend, though. Haley has proven himself to be one of the NFL’s best offensive coordinators. The Steelers are lucky to have him, and fans need to appreciate just how good of a job he has done.