The Pirates could have justified buying or selling at the trade deadline. They opted to do neither, and that was the right decision.
This team isn’t a legitimate World Series contender nor completely out of the playoff hunt, so adding or subtracting players wouldn’t have made much sense. General manager Neal Huntington understood this and essentially swapped a couple of relievers on expiring contracts and added a few low-level minor-leaguers and called it a day.
It was the right approach and works for this year. It works for now, but Huntington and owner Bob Nutting need to understand their credibility is slowly but surely evaporating in the minds of many fans. They can’t keep selling the idea that the future will bring success — they eventually need to deliver success again.
This front office earned plenty of good will by building team that went to the playoffs three years in a row. It shed 20 years of losing and made the Pirates an exciting and up-and-coming organization. It had earned the benefit of the doubt in most of its transactions. But that benefit of the doubt has begun to erode because the two offseasons since winning 98 games in 2015 were disasters. They were disasters because they were based far more on hope than reality.
Hope is not a method, so the Pirates are now stuck in a holding pattern. They needed to build on a 98-win season and take a run at the World Series last season. Instead, they didn’t. They let go of too many essential pieces to that team and replaced them with parts that weren’t as good. They went from 98 wins to 78 wins and blamed it on some of their stars underperforming. Amazingly, there were enough fans who bought it that the Pirates got a bit of a pass. However, last year’s team was going nowhere — even if Gerrit Cole, Andrew McCutchen and Francisco Liriano all had good seasons — because the Cubs improved on a 97-win team that pounded the Pirates in the 2015 wild-card game.
A 78-win season should have been a wake up call to management to make some dramatic changes going into this season. The Pirates did re-sign Ivan Nova, but that was the only move they made of any consequence. That’s where the hope came in. The Pirates hoped a pitching staff loaded with young arms would be good enough. They hoped Josh Bell could play first base. They hoped David Freese and a mix of others would be adequate at third base. They hoped 2015 wasn’t an exception for Francisco Cervelli and that he’d somehow return to that form this year. They also hoped Tony Watson would make a successful switch from set-up man to closer. They hoped Antonio Bastardo’s decline last season wasn’t an optical illusion. They hoped Daniel Hudson’s 1.4 WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched) or higher in three of the past four seasons was an optical illusion too. Some of that has worked out well, like Bell at first base, but most of it has not. The Pirates are average. We see glimpses from the younger players, but numbers don’t lie. They’re not good enough.
Huntington and Nutting need to make sure this offseason is a home run. They need to sign a third baseman — an actual third baseman, not some converted utility infielder — with power and the ability to play every day. They need to find a fourth major-league outfielder — an actual outfielder and not some converted catcher or Class AAA player. They need to bolster their bullpen with at least one more pitcher with a successful track record and then maybe add one of their reclamation projects. It also wouldn’t hurt if they added a veteran starting pitcher, though if they plan to keep Cole through next season this isn’t essential.
These things need to be done if the Pirates want to keep credibility with fans. There are more empty seats this year than last, and fewer people are watching them on TV. In other words, the Pirates’ popularity is fading. Fans are tired the team worrying more about piling up prospects than winning at the major-league level. At some point, the Pirates must emphasize winning in the present and worry about the future later, or they will become an afterthought again and PNC Park will become a ghost town most nights.
The time to make that stand wasn’t Monday’s trade deadline because it didn’t make sense given where the Pirates are in the standings. That time is coming this offseason, though, and it’s up to Huntington and Nutting to make it clear by their actions that they want to win big in 2018.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.