The Pirates’ two best players this season have been Andrew McCutchen and Josh Harrison.
The fact that they — along with the Pirates’ second-best reliever, Juan Nicasio — could be traded (there are rumors the Red Sox are interested in Harrison) speaks volumes about the lack of direction the team has.
The reason McCutchen, Nicasio and Harrison could be dealt is simple: The Pirates are looking to save money.
That has to be it. There is no other explanation for a team wanting to offload three of its best players. Justifications about bolstering the minor league system, creating a spot for Austin Meadows and reloading for next year will surely follow — and it will all be utter nonsense.
The Pirates aren’t that far away from being a wild-card contender. The Rockies and Diamondbacks have come back to Earth. Starling Marte, possibly the Pirates’ best all-around player, returns Tuesday. His return means the outfield again contains three actual outfielders. It also strengthens the bench because either Adam Frazier or David Freese will be left out of the lineup every day. In addition, the Pirates have the second-best starting rotation (by ERA) in July, and Tony Watson and Daniel Hudson have improved to give the bullpen a lift.
The Pirates may not yet be a World Series contender but they can reach the playoffs without much heavy lifting. This isn’t a call for the Pirates to clear out their minor league system and go “all in,” but they certainly shouldn’t be selling assets, either.
Read More
They should look for a couple of cost-effective moves, not cost-cutting moves. Neal Huntington should search for the next J.A. Happ or Ivan Nova and one more decent bat for the bench. Happ and Nova were obtained at the trade deadline in exchange for very little, and the moves seemed insignificant at the time. Of course, they came to Pittsburgh and dominated in the second half of the season.
If the Pirates went to that well again, their starting rotation could become the best in the National League. Chad Kuhl could then move to the bullpen and make that unit even stronger. These aren’t huge moves — one pitcher and one decent bat with position flexibility would add a lot.
That’s all it would take to make a run at the wild card. It wouldn’t cost anything significant in terms of prospects and/or money. The Pirates say they want to win, and this is a great opportunity to prove it. They shouldn’t gut a potentially strong team of its best players, they should make it better. From an on-field perspective, there simply is no logical argument to be made for trading McCutchen or Harrison. It’s a salary dump if either or both are moved before next week’s trading deadline.
The Pirates are good at making excuses for why they can’t make splash moves at the trade deadline and in free agency. A lot of the time, there’s some validity, given their market size and financial limitations. That makes it more difficult to contend for the playoffs every year, but not impossible. They have a chance to get there this year, and there are no excuses for not trying. On top of that, there’s absolutely no spin that will be able to justify trading good players for unproven ones at a time when they have a chance to contend.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.