Pirates president Frank Coonelly said last December he’s “tired of the narrative” that the organization places profits over winning.
“It’s not about profiting,” Coonelly said. “It’s about putting together a winning team, allocating resources to the major league team to win a championship here in Pittsburgh. We need — in the media and otherwise — to talk about a lot of things. But the narrative that we don’t care about winning is just flat wrong. It’s offensive, too, but that’s another matter.”
Unfortunately for Coonelly, there is plenty of evidence to suggest the “narrative” might be true. How else can one explain the way this team was put together and some of its lineups?
This criticism isn’t going away, especially if the season continues on its current course. The Pirates were swept at home by one of the worst teams in baseball and are on pace to win 73 games. If that happens, this would be the seventh losing season in the 10 years under Coonelly and general manager Neal Huntington. To be fair, they spent most of their first two seasons stripping down and rebuilding the organization from top to bottom. Take those two or even three years out of the equation, though, and the picture isn’t that much brighter.
The Pirates didn’t build on their 98 win season of 2015. They didn’t try to extend their string of wild-card games. They called it a bridge year, winning only 78 games, and then in the offseason did very little to upgrade yet again. They re-signed Ivan Nova but other than that opted to go with young, cheaper players. They did have some bad luck with Jung Ho Kang’s legal troubles and Starling Marte’s suspension. Marte was an unexpected loss, but Kang was not. They knew the first week of December they may have to play some or all of this season without him.
Those two would have helped but wouldn’t have made the Pirates legitimate contenders. The pitching is not good enough — too many are training on the job. Then there are the lineups that don’t make sense or give the Pirates the best chance to win. Clint Hurdle had to play minor leaguers early in the season when the Pirates had some injuries. That wasn’t his fault, it was a lack of depth. Now that everyone is healthy, there is no reason to start Max Moroff, who isn’t ready for the majors. Somehow, he started both Saturday and Sunday.
Read More
The Pirates can continue to say they want to win and be offended when fans suggest they don’t. They can continue to blame all of their woes on Kang and Marte. That’s fine, but it’s a sign they think their fans are stupid. The bottom line is that it’s been at least two years since the Pirates have acted like they’re interested in winning a World Series.
Andrew McCutchen discusses NL player of the month honor.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.