One of Clint Hurdle’s best attributes is how he handles his players, especially when they’re in a slump.

This was reinforced by the Andrew McCutchen situation over the past month. McCutchen flirted with the Mendoza line deep into May and was a liability as the No. 3 hitter. However, the Pirates needed McCutchen in the field, especially with Starling Marte’s suspension. There wasn’t a realistic option to bench McCutchen, the team’s best defensive outfielder.

Hurdle wanted to give McCutchen every opportunity to work his way out of his slump but Hurdle also needed him in the outfield. Hurdle also respects his players and understands baseball is hard, even for the best players. When he moved McCutchen to sixth in the lineup, it wasn’t a punitive action — he never said McCutchen was hurting the team, he simply explained that less pressure may help. McCutchen agreed and responded with a huge month, hitting .380 with a .471 on-base percentage, eight home runs and 17 walks in 28 games in the sixth spot.

That performance, combined with Gregory Polanco’s struggles in the No. 3 spot, suggested McCutchen needed to move up. Hurdle, once again, waited and watched as McCutchen figured it out on his own. McCutchen finally called Hurdle on Monday, saying he was ready to move back up in the order. Hurdle agreed, and the move was made.

Advertise with us

McCutchen hit a tying two-run double in the bottom of the ninth Tuesday against the Rays. It didn’t matter because the Rays won in the 10th, but it was a big hit in an at-bat McCutchen wouldn’t have had in the six hole.

Hurdle sometimes makes questionable moves, and his lineups are, at times, mind-boggling. His preference toward certain players — such as John Jaso — can be annoying. However, those criticisms fit with just about every manager in baseball. Not every move is the correct one, and they all have their flaws. The best managers understand how to handle and motivate their players.

Hurdle handled this McCutchen situation perfectly. He allowed it to feel like McCutchen’s decision while making sure he gently, but firmly, guided things in the right direction.

The Pirates haven’t treated McCutchen with a lot of respect the past eight months. They openly talked about his poor defense, then moved him to a different position. They openly tried to trade him. Hurdle, though, handled McCutchen with the respect he deserves, and, in return, got results. He’s now hoping for a similar outcome with Gregory Polanco’s drop in the lineup.

That’s what the best managers do — and that’s why Hurdle is in that group.