Pirates starter Chad Kuhl is a young pitcher with electric stuff and a lively arm. He regularly throws in the mid-90s and has touched 100 mph. He changes speeds well, has an effective slider and is working on his curve ball. He's been valuable but hasn’t been an effective starter by any metric.

In 13 starts this season, Kuhl is 1-6 with a 5.61 ERA, 1.53 WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched) and 4.22 FIP, and opponents are hitting .286 against him. He hasn’t won since April 8 against Atlanta, his first start of the season. The Pirates lost six of the past seven games he started and are 3-10 in games he started. He hasn’t made it past the fifth inning in his past 10 starts and has made it past the fifth inning only twice this season — and both were in April.

The spin has been that he could have pitched longer in recent starts but was lifted for a pinch hitter. That’s technically true, but how many pitchers in a groove are lifted in the fifth inning for a pinch hitter? Kuhl is lifted for pinch hitters because manager Clint Hurdle has little confidence in Kuhl surviving a lineup for a third time.

That lack of confidence is why it’s time for Hurdle to move Kuhl to the bullpen.

Advertise with us

Some scouts say Kuhl projects as a bullpen pitcher long-term. He’s more effective in shorter stints and could become a dominant reliever. He’d also bring a lot to a bullpen still in need of some help.

Moving Tony Watson out of the closer’s role has begun to yield positive results. Felipe Rivero has embraced the closer’s role, and Juan Nicasio has been good in the setup role. Watson has started to round back into form now that he isn’t the closer, and Daniel Hudson has improved. Those four seem to have the back end of the bullpen headed back to the “Shark Tank” days. Teams better get to the Pirates in the first six innings because scoring in the final three could be difficult.

That’s where Kuhl comes in. Wade LeBlanc has served as a long reliever since Trevor Williams moved into the rotation. Kuhl could take that role, and the left-handed LeBlanc could focus on taking out lefty hitters. That specialization is in need with Rivero’s move to closer (or whatever the Pirates want to call him).

Kuhl would give Hurdle the luxury of multiple relievers taking a day off when necessary. Kuhl can pitch three or four innings or longer in certain situations.

The Pirates would have to replace Kuhl in the rotation, but there’s a solution. Steven Brault is 4-3 with 66 strikeouts, a 2.11 ERA and 1.16 WHIP in 68½ innings, allowing only 16 earned runs with Class AAAA Indianapolis. He made seven MLB starts last season, with a subpar ERA (4.86) and WHIP (1.86) and opponent batting average (.313). But that was his first stint as a major-leaguer, and he has progressed since then. He appears to be ready for another shot.

Advertise with us

As the fifth starter, Brault would give the Pirates at least as much as Kuhl, plus he’s a lefty.

If Brault doesn’t work out, Kuhl could move back into the rotation, but the move is a risk worth taking. If it works, it will make the rotation and bullpen better, which would make them more competitive for the rest of the season and beyond.