I’m all for good conspiracy theories, but the ones flying around the Penguins over the past few days would make Oliver Stone blush. The Capitals didn’t wake up Monday morning and discuss the best way to take out Sidney Crosby. Barry Trotz didn’t decide this was the only way his team could beat the Penguins and draw up a plan to pull it off.
Matt Niskanen hit Crosby in what is a very routine play that happens quite often in hockey games. It was a dirty hit and a free shot at a vulnerable player, but it wasn’t over the top or even close to one of the most malicious plays I’ve seen in NHL games.
Crosby was falling down, and Niskanen got his stick up and hit him in the head. Had Crosby still been on his skates, Niskanen’s stick would have hit him in the chest, a hit we see all the time.
Niskanen received a game misconduct and that’s where the discipline should have ended. The NHL saw it that way, which prompted the usual nonsense about how the league is stuck in the old days and doesn’t protect its players.
I thought for a minute that maybe I was being overly kind to Niskanen. That was before I heard former Penguins player and coach Ed Olczyk on 93.7 The Fan Tuesday afternoon discussing the play. He, too, thinks the play wasn’t with malicious intent and didn’t deserve a suspension. He took it a step further and said Niskanen shouldn’t have even been thrown out of the game.
“I felt it was a reactionary play by Matt Niskanen, and those types of plays happen a lot where a guy turns and may run into somebody,” Olczyk said. “It was just one of those plays that went bad.”
Read More
Those are the words of a hockey expert with obvious affection for the Penguins despite being fired by the team in 2005. It’s a rational analysis of the play as it actually happened.
Niskanen said he didn’t try to hurt Crosby, and it’s easy to believe him if you watch the play. He had Crosby in a very vulnerable position and could have lowered the boom to try to injure him but didn’t. Still, the conspiracy theorists are out in force the same way they always are when Crosby is injured. It wouldn’t be so bad if it was limited to fans, but these theories have extended to media members, which is just nuts.
My favorite two conspiracies have a level of sheer lunacy:
No. 1: Matt Niskanen and Sidney Crosby have a history because they got into a fight in a game when Niskanen was in Dallas in 2010.
Seven years is a long time to hold a grudge, but I can definitely see how that would be relevant. It isn’t like he was traded to the Penguins the next season and became Crosby’s teammate for four years or anything.
And it isn’t like Niskanen played against Crosby in last year’s playoffs or a bunch of times in the regular season the last two seasons. No, he waited all this time to find the perfect spot to retaliate and take a cheap shot on Crosby.
That’s as ridiculous as it sounds.
If Niskanen wanted to get Crosby he had plenty of opportunity before Monday. Crosby happened to be the player coming through the crease at that time, and Niskanen lined him up and hit him. I firmly believe if it was anyone else in that same spot, Niskanen would have done the same thing.
No. 2: The Capitals dressed seven defensemen because knew one of their defensemen would be thrown out for taking out Crosby.
First, this requires you to believe that the entire team is sworn to secrecy about a grand plan to take out Crosby. Then it requires you to believe that the Capitals were OK with the idea of losing their best defenseman for the majority of the game. The Capitals would also have had to be OK with the risk of losing him for multiple games if he was suspended. That’s why it makes no sense. If they were going to have a defenseman take Crosby out, wouldn’t they have made sure it was a player that isn’t essential to their chances of winning?
It’s all silly, yet this nonsense has been spewed on talk radio and social media the past few days.
There was no conspiracy to take Crosby out of the game. None. There was no belief that it was the only way they could beat the Penguins, either. Niskanen’s hit was dirty, but it wasn’t with the intent to injure.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.