The Pirates have been without Jung Ho Kang for the entire season and lost Starling Marte to suspension and Adam Frazier to injury in the past week.
The good news is that the Pirates have a deep organization loaded with top prospects just on the verge of stardom. It won’t be long until the cavalry comes up from Class AAA and saves the day. It will happen soon. ... Or that’s at least what the Pirates and their apologists would love for fans to continue to believe — that there is hope right around the corner because this organization is loaded with prospects.
That’s utter nonsense, and frankly, the fact that there are still people who believe this is amazing. The reality is that the strength of the Pirates organization has been highly overrated. Look at the circus in right field and the lack of power and players who could resolve that any time soon. The organization’s best option at fifth starter won the job because every other candidate lost the job.
How is it possible for an organization to have only two legitimate outfielders capable of playing in the major leagues? The Pirates have somehow pulled that off, which is why they’re reduced to using a converted first baseman in right field.
Austin Meadows is supposedly the next great Pirates outfielder. Of course, if he is as good as advertised, why is he not in the majors? Pirates general manager Neal Huntington said Meadows isn’t ready yet. He is struggling to hit in Class AAA Indianapolis (.200 batting average), so there probably is some truth to that. But Meadows is also being held down because the Pirates would like to avoid him achieving Super Two status, which would allow him to reach arbitration before racking up the three years of MLB service time typically required. If the Pirates are truly interested in winning, Meadows should be with the Pirates now. I don’t care if he hits .100 for the next two weeks — he will, at least, give the Pirates a competent defensive right fielder.
Beyond Meadows, look at the Pirates’ farm system and tell me which players are capable of helping this year. Check out this list of the Pirates’ top 10 prospects for 2017, according to Baseball America. Josh Bell and Tyler Glasnow are with the Pirates, and Meadows is listed as the top prospect. After Meadows is Class A pitcher Mitch Keller, who is at least two seasons away. Shortstop Kevin Newman is in Class AA, and third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes is in Class A. This list includes a grading system and probably is even more telling. The Pirates basically have only seven prospects graded high enough to be considered successful major-league players in the future. Six of those seven (Bell is the seventh) are not close to ready. The only two players on that list who might be able to help this year are pitchers Steven Brault and Nick Kingham. I’m not sure either is much more than a fourth or fifth starter, but they might be able to help, at least.
If you believe Glasnow and Chad Kuhl will remain in the rotation, the Pirates have five legitimate competent starters. They need to stay healthy — if the Pirates need more than those five, the options are not exactly stellar. Brault or Trevor Williams would likely be the next man up. Brault appears to be the ultimate “Class AAAA” pitcher, better than Class AAA but worse than MLB. Williams currently is in the bullpen, and the long reliever role probably best suits his talents. After that is Kingham, who isn’t quite ready and, at best, might be a competent fourth starter. Drew Hutchison has shown absolutely no signs he is capable of becoming a major-league starter again, boasting a 0-1 record with a 5.06 ERA in four starts for the Indianapolis Indians.
Huntington has breathed life into the Pirates, but this is shaping up to be the seventh non-playoff season in 10 years. The Pirates have not won a division title on his watch, nor have they won a playoff series. The idea that he is above criticism is ridiculous. The state of this year’s team, with just a few players injured/suspended, is evidence that either Huntington hasn’t drafted well or the organization hasn’t developed well.
Look through all of Huntington’s drafts if you don’t believe me. The 2011 draft brought Gerrit Cole, Tyler Glasnow and Josh Bell, so that could turn out to be a very good one. But look at the barren wasteland of drafts from 2008-10, 2012 and 2013. Those drafts are big reasons the Pirates are where they are in today and why it isn’t likely to improve any time soon. This has happened under Huntington’s watch, so missing Kang and Marte are not excuses for the Pirates missing the playoffs for the second consecutive season.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.