The Pirates 2017 season begins today in Boston, and that means it’s time to make a few predictions.

It has been mostly a quiet offseason for the Pirates, perhaps a little too quiet. They needed to upgrade their pitching staff and did nothing to achieve that. As a result, there’s way too much unknown to feel comfortable with any prediction, good or bad.

Yes, they re-signed Ivan Nova, but he was already in their rotation at the end of last season. That was out of desperation. They needed to get one more veteran pitcher to round out the rotation. Instead, they essentially have three rookies in their rotation.

One of those young pitchers, Jameson Taillon, proved last year he can be an excellent major-league pitcher. Chad Kuhl proved he can scratch and fight his way to five or six solid innings and give the Pirates a chance to win every time he goes out. Tyler Glasnow, however, won his start in the rotation because everybody he was competing with lost. He didn’t pitch well in the spring, but the Pirates are betting on his talent. There are also some legitimate questions about Gerrit Cole (can he bounce back?) and Nova (was last season a fluke?).

Advertise with us

There are other questions about the Pirates, and some don’t have answers.

The Pirates’ infield defense is shaky. First baseman Josh Bell is below average; David Freese and Josh Harrison are average, despite Harrison’s splash plays; and Jordy Mercer is slightly above average. The defense gets even worse if you put Adam Frazier at second and Harrison at third. It isn’t awful, but it isn’t a team strength, either.

The big question is when third baseman Jung Ho Kang arrives — assuming he arrives at all. He is a major variable, an upgrade at the plate and in the field.

There are also questions about the outfield defense with all three outfielders switching positions. Starling Marte will be fine in center, and Andrew McCutchen is veteran enough to handle the move to right. Gregory Polanco is a bit of an unknown because he was still trying to figure some things out in right and now is being asked to field a completely new position.

The lineup without Kang is a bit underwhelming. There are plenty of good hitters, but unless Frazier plays, there doesn’t appear to be a true leadoff hitter. Harrison would make the most sense, but even general manager Neal Huntington has conceded that analytics suggest he isn’t ideal. He doesn’t walk enough and doesn’t get on base enough for that spot. Marte or Polanco can handle the cleanup spot and probably will be asked to do so until Kang returns. Like Harrison, both Polanco and Marte would be better fits in different spots in the lineup. Though there are no home-run hitters, there are enough players who can hit home runs that they should be able to score plenty.

Advertise with us

Catcher is another question facing the Pirates. Francisco Cervelli has been injury prone (played 101 games last season) and is coming off a down year at the plate.

Finally, the Pirates bench is not anywhere close to what it was last year, especially with Freese having to play third in the absence of Kang. Last season, the Pirates had Freese, Matt Joyce and Sean Rodriguez on the bench. All three were capable of pinch-hit home runs. This season, there isn’t a player on the bench Clint Hurdle can turn to for a late inning pinch-hit homer.

As you can see, there are way too many unknowns to feel good about any predictions, but let’s give it it a shot anyway.

Cole and McCutchen will have major bounce-back seasons. The rotation will be better than it was last year, too. Taillon will have a good season, Nova will be solid but not spectacular and the other two rotation spots will be a revolving door. The bullpen is strong, though, so that will help the last two starters in the rotation. Bell will hit like a rookie too often to put up big numbers, and, at times, the Pirates will have to work around his defensive woes. Polanco and Marte will be among the best hitters in the National League.

This all adds up to a solid but not great team. The rotation is not quite good enough to get all the way back to the playoffs. The Pirates will finish 84-78 and miss out on a wild card by two or three games.

While I’m at it, the five playoff teams from the National League will be the Nationals, Cubs, Dodgers, Giants and Rockies, and the Indians will beat the Cubs in a rematch of last year’s World Series.