The Pirates are staring at the reality that they will be without third baseman Jung Ho Kang for a long time. Kang has visa issues that may prohibit him from playing this year, which obviously isn’t good news for the Pirates. He’s their best power hitter, one of their best overall hitters and clearly their best option at third base.
Pirates president Frank Coonelly said the team is trying to resolve the issues with the South Korean government. They should resolve the issues — the Pirates need him.
There is some sentiment that the Pirates should just cut Kang because of his DUIs. He had three, which means he didn’t learn his lesson after the first two. I get it. If he had wrecked and killed someone or hurt someone, I’d agree with cutting him. He didn’t, though, and that changes things completely. I have to believe he learned his lesson throughout this saga. The Pirates should give him one more chance with very strict conditions. However, it might not be their choice, and in the meantime they need to have a plan to replace him.
The easy solution is David Freese. He has experience playing third base and filled in admirably last season while Kang was hurt. Freese hit .270 last season with 13 home runs and 55 RBIs. He also hit 23 doubles and helped carry the Pirates’ offensive load early in the season. But he struggled down the stretch, hitting .247 with just a .333 slugging percentage in the final two months of the season. He also has hit 20 home runs or more only once in eight seasons.
Kang hit 21 home runs last year in only 318 at bats. He was third on the team in homers behind Andrew McCutchen (24) and Gregory Polanco (22). But he had 209 fewer at-bats than McCutchen and 269 fewer than Polanco. He is or was likely to be the Pirates’ cleanup hitter and his power changes the lineup completely. Freese probably is more suited to bat sixth in the lineup. That means the Pirates likely will have to use Starling Marte or Polanco in the fourth spot. Both are capable, but the Pirates would be better suited with them hitting in different spots in the order.
There are some other options at third if Freese falters, but I’m not sure I like any of them. They are:
Read More
• Phil Gosselin: A utility player and pretty good fielder with very little power and an average career on-base percentage (.331). As a bench player, he is wonderful. As a starter, not so much.
• John Jaso: Another player with very little power, Jaso was the full-time first baseman for a stretch last season. He does hit for average, but last season he slumped a bit to .268. Like Gosselin, he is probably best suited as a bench player.
• Josh Harrison: This would require either Alen Hanson or Adam Frazier to play second. That’s probably too many moving parts. Hanson has shown some flashes but has a long way to go, and Frazier is not a good fielder.
• Adam Frazier: He would bring some speed to the top of the lineup but isn’t good enough in the field to handle the position every day.
The reality is that there isn’t really a good option other than Freese, and again, the more he played last season, the worse his numbers got. He has been that kind of player for most of his career, but that doesn’t mean he can’t get the job done and help the Pirates win games. He can, but he would have to be better than he was in the second half of last season. His numbers have declined from early in his career, but he still is capable of putting together a decent season.
Kang did terrible things, but the Pirates aren’t nearly as good without him. They need to work out his issues if they want to be a playoff team this season.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.