Damon Wilson was a four-star player coming out of high school and the gem of Pitt’s 2015 recruiting class. He is now no longer a Panther. The school announced Wednesday that he will transfer.
This has been rumored for weeks. The move in and of itself isn’t something that should set off alarms. Players transfer all the time and for a variety of reasons. Wilson’s reason seems to be mostly related to playing time. But Wilson is the third player to transfer and the fourth to leave the program in the past two weeks. Pitt now has only four returning scholarship players, and that number could be cut in half by the middle of the summer. Redshirt juniors Jonathan Milligan and Rozelle Nix are working hard to finish their degrees, and if they do, they are expected to become graduate transfers.
I understand that roster turnover happens when a coaching change occurs. It isn’t a surprise that Kevin Stallings wants to change the roster. This isn’t roster turnover, though — this is a purge. While it’s probably practical for Stallings if he wants to try to turn the program around quickly, it’s an awful look.
On the Clock: Which conference reigns supreme?
Pitt prided itself on stability for the past 16 years, but the Panthers will have at least nine new players next season.
Freshmen Corey Manigault and Justice Kithcart never seemed to develop. Crisshawn Clark had his third major injury and missed the entire season. Wilson was supposed to have a breakout season but instead couldn’t break into the rotation for a team lacking depth all season. That’s why they all needed to go somewhere else. If they couldn’t get on the court on this team, there’s little chance they would be able to in the future, when Stallings has his own players.
All of that is logical, but it still looks bad for Pitt and even worse for Stallings. True, all of the transfers can be explained, but in the world of recruiting, perception is reality. The perception is that players can’t get out of the program fast enough. That may not be fair, but that’s what opponents and critics will say.
Read More
This approach might work, but there’s a ton of risk as well. Stallings, working for an athletic director who did not hire him, has basically put his future on one recruiting class. Because he already is heading into his second season, he doesn’t have a luxury of more mulligans. There are seven players committed for next season, three of them junior college transfers. Stallings is looking for at least two graduate transfers and may bring in another freshman as well.
If it turns out the majority of those players can actually play at a high level in the ACC, it will be OK. If they can’t, Stallings will have to rebuild the entire roster next season because he doesn’t have the luxury of a a large senior class to free up scholarships. Ryan Luther will be the only player graduating next year if Nix and Milligan leave, as expected. Stallings should consider keeping at least one of those two, if not both. They work hard and have proven to be team players, so there’s no risk in keeping them around. That would leave Stallings with a little bit of wiggle room in case the incoming class isn’t as good as he hopes.
If those two stay in the program and Stallings brings in two graduate transfers for a total of nine new players, he’d have five graduating players next season. That’s five scholarships to give next season without having to move more players out of the program.
In 2018-19, Stallings would have a strong sophomore class and a strong freshman class, at least in terms of numbers. At that point, the program would be back on track to achieving the consistency and stability it enjoyed for almost two decades.
The tricky part is persuading fans, season ticket holders and the new athletic director to be patient while the team takes some lumps. This team isn’t likely to be competitive in the ACC next season, but I suppose anything is possible.
Stallings could pull this off if he has recruited the right kinds of players this season. If he hasn’t — if this huge class isn’t good enough — this plan will blow up, and the program could end up in a tailspin for quite a few years.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.