Tyler Glasnow is considered one of the Pirates’ brightest pitching prospects. At some point, he likely will be a fixture in the rotation and the Pirates hope, he eventually will be one of the top pitchers in the National League.

However, based on his recent performances, he is not yet ready to pitch in the majors full-time. That’s a problem because he is also too good to pitch in the minors. So, the Pirates should keep him in the majors and, for now, use him as a reliever. It makes no sense to send him back to the minors. but it also makes no sense for the Pirates to start the season with him in their rotation.

Glasnow has a high-level fastball and, given his 6-foot-8 frame, a great downhill arm angle. He is intimidating enough, with good velocity, to simply overpower minor league hitters. He had a 1.87 ERA and 1.15 WHIP in Class AAA Indianapolis last season. He pitched 110.1 innings and struck out 133 batters, allowing only 65 hits and 23 earned runs. He did walk 63 batters, which is a bit a too many, but some of that can be explained by the Pirates insisting he work on secondary pitches.

If he went back to Class AAA to start this season, his results would be the same. Minor league hitters have no prayer of success against him, but that doesn’t mean he would be getting better. He still needs to work on consistently controlling his fastball for strikes. He still needs to refine his curveball and develop his changeup. The biggest flaw he seems to have is that he cannot control the opponent’s running game. It’s a work in progress, but he showed Monday he still has work to do in this area.

Advertise with us

Glasnow pitched Monday against the Braves and went 2⅔ innings and got off to a great start, retiring the first six batters he faced. Then in the third inning, he ran into trouble, giving up five runs on six hits. He also had a balk that led directly to the Braves scoring a run.

His numbers are not good for the spring. He has pitched 8⅔ innings and given up 15 hits, 12 earned runs, seven walks and nine strikeouts. He has a 12.46 ERA and 2.19 WHIP. Opponents are hitting .455 against him. Last season, he appeared in seven games for the Pirates and started four. He went 23⅓ innings and struck out 24 but gave up 22 hits, 13 walks and 11 earned runs, with a 4.24 ERA.

Spring training numbers can mean a lot or almost nothing. In this case, though, they mean a lot. The numbers show he needs to develop, but he isn’t going to get the kind of work he needs by blowing away Class AAA hitters.

Pirates manager Clint Hurdle has expressed his concerns about Glasnow on several occasions but also is quick to remind that it’s just spring training and Glasnow is young.

“The game plan was fine for two innings,” Hurdle said. “Now, when the game plan doesn’t work, where do you go with that? Do you point the finger at Ray for the game plan, or do you look at the execution of pitches and where they ended up? I know what we’re going to look at.

Advertise with us

‘When the ball gets elevated up here, it’s hard for anybody to pitch. I think he sat on 94 [mph]. That’s nothing that’s going to rearrange anybody’s mindset at the plate. He’s just got some work to do.”

That sounds to me like Glasnow’s problem is as much about confidence as it is about his ability to locate pitches. He is thinking too much, trying too hard to be great and spooking himself out. That happens with a young pitcher at times, which is why the bullpen would be a great place for him to work on all the things he needs to improve.

In the bullpen, he would be able to pitch in shorter samples. He would have less pressure and be forced to improve his secondary pitches. He would also presumably have more opportunities to pitch from the stretch and work on holding runners. Hurdle could pick and choose the spots to use him and put him in positions to succeed.

Obviously, the long-term plan would be to stretch him out and put him in the rotation. In the short term, he would be in the bullpen and in the majors working on his game. That seems like the best path for Glasnow. He is talented with a bright future, and the Pirates need to make sure they help him find his way.