Jim Ferry is yet another basketball coach with a track record of success who came to Duquesne and apparently forgot how to coach and win games.

It’s amazing how that seems to happen over and over again at Duquesne. And yet, here we are again, with another Duquesne athletic director telling the world he will get it right this time.

“Duquesne’s goal is to be a highly-valued member of the Atlantic 10 Conference,” athletic director Dave Harper said in a statement. “Success in men’s basketball is paramount to that strategy. Starting today, we will begin a national search.”

I already wrote the reasons why firing Ferry is a mistake. I could have written the same exact column about Ron Everhart when he was fired and just changed the names and dates.

Advertise with us

Duquesne needs stability, it needs a long-term plan and it needs a little patience. Ferry represented that, but he’s gone, so there’s no reason to revisit that discussion. That means it’s time to look to the future.

How could anyone look at the future of Duquesne men’s basketball and not see anything more than two more news conferences? The first will be a few weeks from now, when they hire whatever poor sucker they can find. The second will be in about five years when Harper, or whoever is athletic director at that point, announces he has fired that same coach.

I hate to be that cynical, but what evidence exists that the administration will get it right this time? Oh that’s right, there are facilities renovations coming, so they’re really serious now. Well, sort of. They aren’t sure yet because the funding isn’t totally in place.

If Duquesne doesn’t first fix its main problem — an administration that clearly has no idea how to be successful in men’s basketball — it won’t matter. The school can build all the new facilities money can buy, hire and fire 10 more coaches and even drop down to a lower-level conference, and it won’t change a thing. Duquesne first needs to figure out who it is and what it wants from its men’s basketball program. The school needs to understand what is realistic and what is not. There are two great examples of what the Dukes should aspire to in the Atlantic 10: St. Bonaventure and St. Joseph’s, fellow Catholic universities with similar limitations.

Both of those programs have had some degree of success over the years, while Duquesne has been a disaster. That’s mostly because the administrations know who they are and what they are capable of and don’t fire coaches after a few bad seasons. They understand success over the long term is only a product of stability at the top. That is why Phil Martelli and Mark Schmidt have both been in place for long time (more than two decades for Martelli), even though they miss the NCAA tournament more than they make it. Duquesne shouldn’t start a coaching search until it figures this out and commits what it takes to get it right.

Advertise with us

Then the problem becomes finding a coach to take the job. What coach in his right mind would take this job if he has any other opportunities or cares about his future? This isn’t just a bad job, it’s a career-ending job, or at least that’s what it has been. The last eight coaches at Duquesne all have been fired. Yes, technically Danny Nee and Darelle Porter “resigned,” but so did Richard Nixon and nobody believes it was his choice, either.

Take it one step further: Only one of the seven Duquesne coaches prior to Ferry landed another Division-I coaching job. That was Scott Edgar, who bounced around as an assistant for eight years before landing at Southeast Missouri State.

That’s why it’s comical Dukes fans believe they can lure a young hotshot from a smaller school or a top assistant from a high-profile program. There is no reason for any young coach to make that move, and this is not a job for an assistant who never has been a head coach.

That doesn’t mean there isn’t a coach out there who will take the Duquesne job and maybe even one who is capable of doing a good job. There are coaches who have had some success in the Atlantic 10, such as Brian Gregory and Bruiser Flint, who aren’t currently head coaches and may be interested in taking a shot. There is also the 800-lb gorilla in the room, Mike Rice, who honestly would be the best coach they could hire and even has ties to the program.

It’s going to be tough for Harper to find a good coach without baggage, but it’s a problem he created by firing Ferry instead of working with him to help him be successful.

The best athletic directors don’t generally fire coaches. They hire the right coaches and support them through tough times. What’s done is done, though, and now it’s up to Harper to make it right.