Kevin Stallings isn’t blameless for this disaster of a Pitt season. But it was his first season with the Panthers, so he should mostly receive a pass from fans and media alike.

The Panthers didn’t have a single player that Stallings recruited, and too many of them didn’t seem to buy what he was selling. He inherited a roster with no point guard, no post presence of any kind and very little depth. Those three shortcomings were consistently exploited by opponents, especially once the ACC season began. He also had a senior class that hasn’t always been the most coachable group. The seniors lacked interest and focus on the defensive end and, at times, were selfish.

It’s fair to say the roster may have been a few wins better than its record, but not many. I’d chalk that up to the coaching transition, which usually will have some hiccups. Stallings’ philosophy is the polar opposite of Jamie Dixon’s in just about every way, and he had a veteran team used to doing things a certain way.

However, this team looked disinterested or just flat-out quit in too many games. It also blew too many leads and lost too many close games because of poor execution in the second half. That’s on Stallings, as is giving his team offensive freedom without making it prove it can handle it. That backfired — Pitt’s shot selection early in the season would make Kobe Bryant blush.

Advertise with us

Stallings also was too slow to truly take on Mike Young and Jamel Artis. He was trying to win and needed those two in order to achieve that, but they wanted to do things their way and brought the whole team down.

Freshmen Justice Kithcart and Corey Manigault didn’t develop, and both may have actually gotten worse as the season progressed.

All of these things happened on Stallings’ watch and give reason for pause about his ability to be successful. Now that his first season is over, Stallings’ benefit of the doubt has also come to an end. This is Stallings’ program now, and going forward he will have to answer for it.

Stallings already has seven incoming recruits and has indicated there likely will be at least one or two more. That means the roster will include Ryan Luther, Cam Johnson and as many as nine new players recruited by Stallings. All of the excuses about Dixon’s players will no longer be acceptable because the roster will be full of Stallings’ players.

The Panthers are basically starting over with a new roster, and there will be growing pains. That can’t be an excuse for being blown out regularly and finishing tied for 13th in a 15-team league again. If the roster next year isn’t good enough, it will be Stallings’ fault. He recruited and signed all of the new players, and it is up to him and his staff to develop them into a functional, competitive ACC team. If next year’s roster doesn’t have a point guard or a post player who can compete in the ACC, Stallings has nobody to blame but himself.

Advertise with us

Blowing up a roster and starting over is a highly risky move. If the majority of the players Stallings recruited are good enough, it will work out. If the class is a bust, it will be a total disaster with devastating long-term consequences.

That doesn’t mean that Stallings has to win the ACC or even get to the NCAA tournament next year. The Panthers need to play much better than they did this year and show some semblance of consistent progress. They also need to be better at the end of the season than they are at the start. They need to take a step forward or risk becoming the ACC’s new Boston College. That is to say: a once-competitive and perennial NCAA tournament contender lost in a wilderness and stuck in an extended funk.

The Panthers’ future starts today, and it’s now in Stallings’ hands. There will be no more grading on a scale and no more acceptable excuses. It’s his program with his players and his name on the bottom line.