The Pirates are considering a couple of different options for leadoff hitter, but their best option doesn’t seem to be in the conversation. The job likely belongs to Josh Harrison because he handled the duties adequately for the final 33 games before he was injured last season.
Harrison looks the part — fast, energetic and able to steal a few bases — but numbers suggest otherwise. Starling Marte isn’t the perfect leadoff hitter because he strikes out too much and doesn’t draw enough walks, but he is a much better option than Harrison.
Marte was among the top 20 qualified hitters in the National League in on-base percentage (.362), stole 47 bases last season and has had 30 or more steals in each of the last four seasons. He led the team with 34 doubles last season (tied with Gregory Polanco) and hit five triples, but he doesn’t really hit for power or drive in many runs. So, batting him fourth or fifth doesn’t seem to make a whole lot of sense. Marte hit 19 home runs and drove in 81 runs in 2015, but that was the only season he had middle-lineup power numbers.
Last season he hit only nine home runs and drove in 46 runs, but his batting average (.311) and on-base percentage skyrocketed. The Pirates wouldn’t be sacrificing his RBI potential by moving him up in the order. He also struck out only 104 times, his fewest in four seasons as a full-time player. That shows improved discipline, and if that trend continues he could limit his strikeouts to 100 or less.
There is more that goes into being a leadoff hitter than just a high on-base percentage, though Marte’s .362 in 2016 was far superior to Harrison’s .311. Marte also stole more bases than Harrison (47 to 19) and hit more doubles (34 to 25). That means Marte is more likely to move into scoring position, setting the table for early runs, than Harrison.
Harrison is a good hitter, he just isn’t a good fit as a leadoff hitter. He did have his best stretch hitting .326 with 10 doubles in 33 games as the Pirates’ leadoff hitter until his season was cut short by a groin injury. But because Marte, Josh Bell, Andrew McCutchen, Jung Ho Kang and Polanco should occupy the Pirates’ first five spots in the lineup, Harrison would be a better option lower in the order.
Kang’s status throws a bit of a wrench in this plan early in the season. If the Pirates start the season without Kang, Harrison could lead off, and Marte would hit fourth or fifth. But that would only be temporary.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.