The Steelers signed James Harrison to a two-year deal Wednesday, which isn’t a surprise. Harrison said at the end of the season he wasn’t ready to retire. The deal is a win for both parties. He wanted to keep playing, and the Steelers need his pass-rushing ability. He is a tough, emotional leader and his presence in the locker room is invaluable.
Harrison fills a need but will be 39 in May. The signing is a mistake if the Steelers are counting on him to be a full-time starter for an entire season. It wasn’t a coincidence the Steelers’ defense improved dramatically last season roughly about the same time Harrison was elevated to full-time status. He played almost every defensive snap in the final five games, but that was out of necessity. The defense had issues, and Mike Tomlin realized the rotation of outside linebackers wasn’t working. He settled on Harrison and Bud Dupree to man the two outside positions, and the pass rush improved.
That worked in a short sample of games, but Harrison needs to go back to playing part-time if the Steelers want him to be as effective as possible. This site tracks the number of snaps each player in the NFL logs. Harrison played between 40 and 50 percent of the snaps leading up to Week 12, when his work load increased. He played 74 defensive snaps in the Steelers’ Week 16 win against the Ravens. That is a feat for a 28-year-old linebacker, much less 38. That isn’t sustainable over 16 games, so the Steelers need to draft another outside linebacker who can split time with and learn from Harrison.
Though he was the Steelers’ leader in sacks last season, he only had five. If Harrison took a rookie under his wing, it would allow him to be a situational player. That could increase his sack numbers. A rested and healthy Harrison for the playoffs should be the Steelers’ goal, but that will only happen if they find someone to share snaps with him. Harrison would be best served to start the season playing 80 percent of the snaps and slowly being reduced to about 60 percent by the end of the season. That would give him the best opportunity to be fresh down the stretch and in the playoffs, when he could be used specifically in passing situations to pose a big problem for opposing offenses.
Anthony Chickillo and Arthur Moats proved they aren’t good enough to split time with Harrison or Dupree. Chickillo has been solid on special teams, and Moats is an adequate back-up. The Steelers aren’t likely to sign a top outside linebacker in free agency, so they need to find one in the draft.
That was supposed to be the plan with Jarvis Jones, and it didn’t work out, mostly because they miss-evaluated him. That doesn’t mean the Steelers should stop trying to fill that role. They got it right using first round picks on Dupree and linebacker Ryan Shazier, and they can do it again.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.