There were many factors in the Pirates’ failure to reach the playoffs last season, but the biggest was that their pitching rotation simply wasn't good enough.

Jon Niese, Juan Nicasio and Jeff Locke were three of their five starters, and that alone eliminated them as a playoff contender. Gerrit Cole and Francisco Liriano struggled, which didn't help, but they couldn't have pitched well enough to carry the Pirates to the playoffs, given the back end of their rotation. Niese and Locke are gone, and Nicasio is in the bullpen, so the Pirates have a chance to upgrade their rotation.

Cole and Jameson Taillon are a strong 1-2 punch, and that's a good start. Ivan Nova will start the home opener and be either third or fourth in the rotation. Manager Clint Hurdle hasn't announced the final two spots, but Chad Kuhl and Drew Hutchison are heavy favorites to earn those roles.

If that’s the rotation, it seems like an upgrade over the start of last season, but only time will tell. Nova, Hutchison and Kuhl all have ability, but how well all three will pitch is a complete mystery. At least they’re an upgrade on paper over the back three last year — we were certain those three stunk. With this trio, there’s hope, but hope is all it really is at this point.

Advertise with us

Kuhl, in his first season as a full-time starter, is too young to know what he will do. We have an idea of what he is capable of, based on what we saw last season. However, that was a small sample size. He isn't going to blow anyone away with his stuff, and he typically won’t go deep into games. But he is an intense competitor and will battle, and that's his edge.

Nova pitched two perfect innings Tuesday and said he feels better than he ever has in spring training. The question is whether he will be the journeyman he has been for most of his career or the pitcher from the second half of last season with a 3.06 ERA?

Hutchison was the Blue Jays’ opening day starter in 2015 but has been through the pitching wilderness ever since. The Pirates acquired him at the trade deadline last season and sent him to the minors, but they believe that they can revive his career.

If all three, or even two of the three, are able to become what the Pirates project, this could be a bounce-back season. I believe Cole will rebound and Taillon will be good, so they will get more production from their top two starters than last year. However, it still comes down to the bottom three starters. Though the Pirates appear to be better in that area this year, it remains to be seen.

Games aren't won on paper, and hope doesn’t win games, but there is at least hope. Last year, there was none. We won't know anything until the season begins and those three actually pitch.