The idea of “bullpenning” may never actually catch on in Major League Baseball, but if ever there was a team that could use some of those principles, it is the Pirates.

The bullpen appears to be the Pirates’ strength this year. It is deep with a good mix of righties and lefties, including a couple guys who can throw really hard.

While there could be three closer candidates — Tony Watson, Felipe Rivero and Daniel Hudson — the Pirates seem to be set on using Watson in that role.

That’s a mistake. Not because Watson isn’t capable of doing a good job as a closer but because the Pirates shouldn’t limit Watson to save situations.

Advertise with us

This is where some of the principles of bullpenning come in. Clint Hurdle should not be afraid to think outside the box in how he uses Rivero, Hudson and Watson.

There will be some games where the Pirates get in a jam in the sixth or seventh inning and at that point, Hurdle shouldn’t go to some pre-determined formula to try and get out of it.

He should be free to use Watson if it makes the most sense and know that he can come back with Hudson or Rivero to close the game.

Rivero probably has the best arm and nastiest stuff. Watson is probably the best overall pitcher of the three, and Hudson might be the best guy to get through multiple innings.

All three, though, are more than capable of serving as the closer at times, and they should all be viewed as such by Hurdle.

Advertise with us

The model for this was the way that Indians manager Terry Francona used his bullpen arms in the World Series, and while some of what he did isn’t practical in the regular season, he showed how using his best pitcher in different situations can be a huge factor in winning.

The Pirates don’t have a weapon quite as good as Andrew Miller, but they have enough good pitchers that they should be able to close out games out regardless of how long the starter goes.

The only reason there is a designated closer these days is because of the save statistic. A number of managers admit they’d probably use their bullpen differently if the “save” didn’t exist.

I asked former Pirates pitcher and current broadcaster Bob Walk about this the other day, and he went one step further and said if it weren’t for the save, most managers would be a lot better at handling their bullpens.

That’s because if there is a designated closer and even worse, a designated eighth inning guy as well, it really cuts down on the manager’s ability to make decisions based on what each circumstance dictates.

Advertise with us

Yes, it was nice when the Pirates had the security of Watson to pitch the eighth and Mark Melancon to pitch the ninth, but there were a number of games where both could have been better used in earlier innings.

Now that Melancon is gone, Hurdle should rethink his bullpen strategy, and that’s especially true considering Watson is a pitcher that may very well find himself on the trading block at the deadline.

Watson, Rivery and Hudson are weapons, but only if they are used correctly. They won’t be used correctly if the script is already written about when they will enter the game.