Gerrit Cole said earlier this week that he is physically and mentally ready to have a bounce-back season. That’s good news because he’s the Pirates’ most important player, and they’re going nowhere unless he returns to form.

The Pirates might be able to overcome a bad season by Andrew McCutchen, Francisco Cervelli, Jung Ho Kang or Josh Harrison, but I can’t make that argument with Cole. If Cole doesn’t regain his form as an ace, the Pirates have zero chance of being a playoff team. They still might not earn a playoff spot even if Cole is great, but if he isn’t, this season will be a waste.

There are enough good hitters — or potentially good hitters — on the roster to overcome a bad season by one or even two of their top fielders. It wouldn’t be ideal, but it wouldn’t be impossible, either. That’s not the case when it comes to pitching. There are far too many questions right now, and that’s especially true if Cole doesn’t have a big season.

Some people forget just how good Cole was in 2015 when he was one of the biggest reasons the Pirates had one of their best seasons in team history. These people seem to think Cole either is overrated or isn’t ace material. They often compare him to players like Clayton Kershaw and Jake Arrieta as definitive proof he isn’t a true ace. That 2015 season proved he is and can be an ace, and without Cole, the Pirates wouldn’t have won 80 games that year. He was that good that season.

Advertise with us

He got rocked in the wild-card game by the Cubs, and for some reason that’s all some people seem to remember about Cole’s season. But he was spectacular and finished fourth in the National League Cy Young voting and even received a few votes for National League MVP. He was 19-8 with a 2.60 ERA, a 1.09 WHIP and went 208 innings with 202 strikeouts and only 44 walks. If those aren’t ace numbers, I’m not sure what are. He doesn’t quite have to do that again, but he needs to be pretty darn close.

I don’t see anyone else on the staff capable of putting up those kinds of numbers and being the lead dog. Jameson Taillon could develop into an ace, but he is only in his second season post-surgery. Last year, he was on a pretty clear innings and pitch count.  The Pirates need Taillon to be good too, but given his history of injuries I’m not sure he can be relied on to pitch 200+ innings.

Ivan Nova was successful for the Pirates in the second half of last season, but he has pitched 160 innings or more in a season just twice in his career. He has had an ERA below 4.00 only once. He looks far more like a middle of the rotation guy than the Pirates’ best pitcher down the stretch last season. Taillon and Nova are supposed to be the two known quantities behind Cole, but beyond those two are a bunch of players with very little experience and/or low ceilings. That’s why Cole is so essential to this season and why the Pirates have no chance without him.

An argument could be made that Taillon has ace stuff, Drew Hutchison could be Ray Searage’s latest reclamation project, Nova proved he can be a great National League pitcher and two of the young prospect types can fill the back of the rotation, but that’s a pipe dream.

The Pirates need Taillon and Nova to be good regardless, but Cole is the key to everything.