This is a very different year for the Pirates. They face more questions than usual, and I’m not sure there are answers to them all.

On Sunday, Bill Brink wrote about some of these questions, and let me expand on that.

Neal Huntington again reminded us Friday on 93.7 The Fan why the Pirates likely always will fall a little short under his watch. Huntington said a trade for Jose Quintana would have required too many prospects in return, and that would be, in effect, mortgaging the future.

“The best way to position ourselves to win a World Series is to get to the playoffs consistently and frequently,” Huntington said. “And we’re not of the mindset that the way to do that is to jeopardize your future for your present or to jeopardize your present for your future. We want to be a good team as consistently and frequently as possible and the only way to do that in a small market is to have a lot of good players, to have a lot of good players in your system, and a trade of that magnitude would have been contradictory to those goals.”

Advertise with us

He is making a mistake when it comes to Qunitana because he isn’t a rental player, he has four years of team control. That would mean, for the next three seasons, the Pirates could have Jameson Taillon, Gerrit Cole, Ivan Nova and Jose Quintana in their rotation. They wouldn’t need to scour for reclamation projects and bargain basement pitchers to fill out their staff every year and could focus on other areas. That’s the situation they’re in this year, needing to find two starters to fill out their rotation. No matter what pitchers they end up with, they won’t be good enough to keep the Pirates in contention for the National League Central Division title.

Chad Kuhl will give the Pirates an honest effort every night, but he isn’t a long-term answer in the rotation, and Tyler Glasnow is just not ready yet. So, this is an important spring for a pitching staff that is not nearly as good as the teams the Pirates are competing with for a playoff spot. The bullpen should be good but could struggle if Tony Watson doesn’t make a smooth transition to full-time closer.

Jung Ho Kang’s legal mess and Andrew McCutchen’s new position and ability to rebound are two more important questions Brink discusses in the story above, but here a few others:

1. Josh Bell’s defense — Remember when Pedro Alvarez was run out of town because he was a poor fielding first baseman? By all measures, Bell is not a good fielder, yet has been handed the job. He has a long way to go to become a good or even competent fielder, and that starts in spring training.

2. Who will be the lead-off hitter? — Analytics suggest Josh Harrison isn’t a great lead-off hitter, Gregory Polanco can produce runs and Starling Marte isn’t a great fit, either, The lineup will be interesting with McCutchen hitting third again, but what if he falters to start the season?

Advertise with us

3. Francisco Cervelli’s health — He is an elite pitch framer but didn’t have much success at the plate last season. He dealt with nagging injuries, so the Pirates had to rely on backups. Cervelli’s injury history isn’t favorable, but he needs to stay healthy and find his hitting stroke again.

Generally, these kinds of questions sort themselves out in spring training, but there seems to be more uncertainty this year than the past five seasons. That’s not good for any franchise, especially one coming off a 78-win season and has done very little to upgrade its roster. That’s especially true in a division with the defending World Series champions, who are a threat to win 100 games or more again.