I figured that by this point in the season I would be writing about how Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford has to trade Marc-Andre Fleury in order to remove any goaltending distractions heading into the playoffs.

The Penguins could use some help on defense, maybe even another wing, or could flip Fleury for some prospects and future draft picks, all the while clearing the way for this to become Matt Murray’s team. But after watching the first half of the season, I’ve changed my opinion and believe trading Fleury before the end of the season would be the wrong move.

It isn’t a problem to have two good goaltenders, and as we’ve seen in recent weeks, injuries are a factor in the NHL. The Penguins have the luxury of having a very good insurance policy on the bench regardless of which goaltender gets hurt.

There’s a very real possibility the Penguins could lose Fleury in the offseason to the expansion draft, but that can’t be a consideration because the Penguins can win the Stanley Cup right now. Rutherford is savvy and smart and aggressive, and he will do everything in his power to make sure the Penguins can get something in return for Fleury if they have to lose him. But even if they don’t, the possibility of losing him can’t be the reason to move him at the trade deadline.

Advertise with us

The Penguins need both goaltenders to get through the grind of the season. Even though Murray has been much better in goal, Fleury has proven he can still play at a high level. That’s why Rutherford should hold on to Fleury and keep the Penguins as one of the few teams that can boast two goaltenders capable of winning the Stanley Cup.

That doesn’t mean coach Mike Sullivan won’t have to make a choice between the two before the playoffs. Alternating goaltenders wouldn’t work in the playoffs. And because Murray has played better this season and was in goal when the Penguins won last year’s Cup, Fleury has to beat out Murray in the last 42 games in order to play in the playoffs.

That won’t sit well with the goaltender who is the odd man out, but as we saw last year, Fleury was a good, loyal teammate and supported Murray throughout the playoffs. So, this situation shouldn’t become toxic.

Murray has been better at alternating starts. By Fleury’s own admission, he has a hard time staying sharp when he doesn’t get to play regularly. He wasn’t great Wednesday night against the Capitals, but the loss wasn’t squarely on his shoulders. However, his five prior starts were very good, possibly because he played more regularly over the past month after Murray was awful in a Dec. 22 loss to Columbus and injured Dec. 28.

Fleury has proven he can still be one of the best goaltenders in the league, and that’s good enough to say he needs to remain with the Penguins and push Murray for the starting job.