When I first heard the news about who may start at QB for the Colts against the Steelers, my reaction was, “What in the heck is a Scott Tolzien?”

Scott Tolzien? Are you kidding me?

Allow me to whine, I mean rant, for a moment, because this is the most disappointing news I’ve heard this week, which probably means it has been a good week, but that isn’t relevant right now.

But this is what I get to watch Thursday night instead of the prime time matchup I, and presumably many others, were eagerly anticipating for the past few weeks.

Advertise with us

It was supposed to be Andrew Luck vs. Ben Roethlisberger, one of the rare times these days that an NFL game features two top-shelf quarterbacks, two guys who are both capable of carrying their team on their backs to a win.

We already got hosed out of watching Roethlisberger face Tom Brady this season and instead got to watch Landry Jones play that day, but now we miss out on Luck-Roethlisberger too, and that just doesn’t seem fair.

This was supposed to be a game that featured somewhere in the neighborhood of 800 yards passing and 8-9 touchdown passes, big plays and lots of fun.

Instead, it will feature Scott Tolzien.

I know Steelers fans are probably saying, “Well our team really needs a win, and this all but assures we will get one, so I’m happy Andrew Luck is out.” But deep down, admit it, you’d much rather watch an exciting game than a boring game.

Advertise with us

I’m not happy at all that Luck is likely not going to play due to a concussion. Obviously my first concern is for the health of a young talented player who has taken a beating because his offensive line stinks, and head injuries are a serious matter.

But as a fan of football, like many fans this year, I’m starving for entertaining games, as there just haven’t been enough of them.

That’s especially true on Thursday night, a time slot in which the NFL has basically decided it doesn’t care about ratings. That is the only conclusion one can come to after looking at the matchups the league chooses to put on every week. A lot of it has to do with quarterback play and the fact that there are too many mediocre ones starting games.

Two weeks ago when the Steelers played against Dallas, even though it was a loss, it was entertaining. Both offenses were explosive and a threat to score on just about every drive.

This past weekend in Cleveland wasn’t so exciting as it was very clear the Browns offense, because of underwhelming quarterback play, was not going to be able to score enough points to win.

Advertise with us

As a result, the Steelers were ultra conservative on offense and basically just tried to avoid big mistakes that would give the Browns a chance.

That’s what I anticipate Thursday. The Colts offense will be extremely limited, and the Steelers will do just enough to control and win the game.

Maybe Tolzien is going to channel his inner “Commander” Cody Carlson (look it up, youngsters) and come off the bench to throw all over the Steelers defense and pull off a shocking upset.

But as much as I have faith in Paul Chryst’s ability as a quarterback whisperer — Tolzien played at Wisconsin and Chryst was his offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach — this guy hasn’t started a game since 2013 and hasn’t attempted 100 passes in a career that began in 2011.

I know anything is possible and any given Sunday (or Thursday) and all that stuff, but let’s face it, the Colts will go only where Luck can take them, and if he isn’t in the game they aren’t likely to go anywhere.

Advertise with us

I hope I’m wrong. I hope I’m selling Tolzien way too short, but I have a sneaking suspicion I’m not.

Luck-Roethlisberger would have been an excellent way to finish off Thanksgiving, especially on the heels of what should be a very entertaining game between the Cowboys and Redskins.

But alas, on a day I’m celebrating the many things I am thankful for, I’m fairly certain one of them won’t be the opportunity to watch the Tolzien-led Colts slop their way to 13 points or so.

That may seem harsh, but Tolzien made two starts in that 2013 season, and in both games he led the Packer to 13 points.

I suppose I can be thankful there will be leftover turkey and apple pie to eat while watching this game.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com