There probably is no greater example of why an NFL coach should not have absolute final say over personnel decisions than the Cleveland Browns.

The Browns are the NFL’s punchline, an answer to every joke about bad coaching decisions and even worse quarterback play, and clearly they are a threat to go 0-16 this season. Things have been so bad for the Browns that they turned the franchise over to a baseball executive and hope that he can use analytics to become the NFL’s version of Theo Epstein.

But it really didn’t have to be this way, had the franchise just made one decision differently in 2004. Really, the bad decision-making began in 2001.

That was the year the Browns hired Butch Davis to be the head coach, a decision unto itself that may or may not been the correct one. But we will never know because they were so desperate to hire him that they gave him full control and final say over personnel decisions.

Advertise with us

I’ve watched the NFL a long time, and I’ve come to the conclusion — and most organizations have, too — that giving an NFL coach the final power over personnel decisions is a bad move.

There has to be some checks and balances, and there has to be someone in the organization that isn’t looking at the small picture of the “the next season” to be able to step in and say, “No, we aren’t doing that.”

That’s what I have concluded about the Browns and Davis after about three days of reading and researching about the 2004 draft and why in the world they took a tight end (Kellen Winslow II) instead of Ben Roethlisberger.

Had there been somebody in the organization who had the authority to tell Davis, “No,” the last 12 or 13 seasons of the Browns and the Steelers, who meet on Sunday, would probably have been totally different.

The Steelers probably wouldn’t have added two Super Bowls to their trophy case, while the Browns may have won one or two long before the Cavaliers turned the city into “Believeland.”

Advertise with us

It may even be argued that had somebody in that organization stepped in and said “no” to Davis, he would still be coaching the Browns instead of telling the world how excited he is to be named the head coach at Florida International.

The Browns had the No. 7 pick in the NFL draft in 2004, and they were so hell bent on drafting Winslow, who was recruited by Davis to Miami, that they traded up one spot with the Lions for the No. 6 pick.

Davis wanted Winslow because he thought he was a difference maker and believed that, in signing Jeff Garcia, they had properly addressed the quarterback position.

There are a bunch of different stories on the internet about it — here is one with the basics — but the story goes they believed that Winslow was a safer, surer bet than Roethlisberger.

Former Browns executive Pete Garcia tells the story of the day he, Davis and a few others went to Miami (Ohio) and worked out Roethlisberger just before the draft and almost took him.

Advertise with us

Garcia had the title, but Davis had the power (he also had a title of vice president along with head coach) and the final say, and ultimately he knew he needed to win that season to keep his job.

So he took Winslow, a tight end who played in only one Pro Bowl, instead of Roethlisberger, and the rest is very well documented history.

The cynic would say the Browns are so awful they would have ruined Roethlisberger like they seem to do every quarterback, but I take the opposite approach; they have never had a legitimate franchise QB in place before.

If they had Roethlisberger, they would have been able to build a team around him and not worry about floundering around and kicking the tires of every journeyman quarterback on the planet.

And I truly believe that if Davis was in his first season with the Browns, he would have made the right pick and gone with the quarterback, and I’d say that even if it was one of these quarterbacks that didn’t turn out.

Advertise with us

A franchise quarterback changes a franchise’s outlook for a decade or longer, but there is no tight end or receiver and very, very few running backs about whom you could make the same claim.

But again, when a coach, especially one who needs to win, makes these decisions without anyone having the ability to veto it, I think it leads to disaster for a franchise.

Nobody is sure of the split of powers between Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin, and I’m sure Tomlin has a large say in personnel. But I’d be willing to bet that if he was going to make a decision that Colbert thought was an awful decision, he could be overruled.

For a number of years, the “coach has the final say” mantra was what teams seemed to be signing up for at alarming rates, but that has seemingly changed as teams have realized it is way too much power to give to a coach.

The best organizations seem to have a team of personnel guys, a clear general manager and coach, who all work together on draft day and in making other personnel decisions. That doesn’t mean the coach, whose job is most on the line and based on the team’s record, shouldn’t have MORE say than the others and a large degree of input, but there always has to be someone else who can say no.

Advertise with us

I’m sure people will say, “The Patriots, the Patriots.” Yes, there are exceptions to every rule.

Now the Browns have a team of personnel guys in place that has been assembled by “moneyball” executive Paul DePodesta, so the future looks bright ...

Except this group may have made the same mistake Davis made as they passed on drafting QB Carson Wentz this year and opted instead to trade the pick for more draft picks.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com