The Pirates need veteran pitchers for next year, but because of their budget, can’t get involved with long-term or even medium-term deals to bring them to town.
I get it. They don’t want to lock up their money in bad contracts they can’t get out of, and while some people don’t want to hear that, that is a legitimate economic reality of being a small market team.
I will give them a pass if they pass on Ivan Nova, Doug Fister, Rich Hill and maybe even Edison Volquez. All of those guys are likely to get overpaid for multi-year deals because there just isn’t enough pitching on the market.
But I said at the start of this offseason, the Pirates needed to be aggressive and find an affordable option to bolster their rotation for next year. They still have way too many young pitchers who need more seasoning before they can be trusted in the rotation.
And to that end, they again sat on their hands and missed on a real opportunity to make themselves better when they didn’t pursue free agent pitcher Bartolo Colon.
Colon signed a one-year, $12.5 million deal with the Braves, and that is exactly the kind of deal the Pirates should have been all over, especially for a pitcher like Colon.
The Braves, who have more money than the Pirates but like the Pirates have a lot of young arms they are grooming and wanted to be able to continue to develop next year, took two moves from the Pirates as they also got veteran R.A. Dickey on a one-year, $8 million deal.
Dickey would be a very nice fifth starter, but I think Colon could really help the Pirates get back into contention next year. And from what I am told by a few people I trust, the Pirates didn’t even really kick the tires on him to see if he’d be interested. That was a big mistake.
People look at Colon’s age (43) and his weight (more than 280 pounds), and they scoff at the idea that the Pirates or anyone else would be interested in him.
His weight and the fact that he doesn’t exactly look like a model of fitness is really why so many people who don’t look at the pitcher seem to be so clueless as to just how good he has been.
I discussed this Friday night on my talk show and actually had some people say Colon is unreliable because he isn’t in shape and is likely to break down.
Nothing could be further from the truth. Colon has registered 190 innings or more in each of the last four seasons, and that includes this past season where he went 191⅔ innings.
In 19 seasons, he has pitched 180 innings or more 12 times and hasn’t pitched less than 150 innings since 2010.
And yes, he is 43 years old, but he seems to have the Jaromir Jagr-like fountain of youth in that he is still a very effective player.
Look at his numbers this past season: a WHIP of 1.21, an ERA of 3.43 and he still averages six strikeouts per nine innings, which isn’t an overwhelming number but shows he can still get it done.
He was also 15-8 on a team that struggled to score runs, and that marked the fifth consecutive season he had double digit wins. If you compare his numbers to the two young studs on the staff — Noah Syndergaard and Jacob deGrom — you would be shocked at how well Colon stacks up.
Now compare this to the Pirates staff. Their innings leader this year was Jeff Locke with 127⅓, and they had no pitcher reach double figures in wins. Their wins leader was, you guessed it, Locke with nine.
Colon is exactly the kind of pitcher the Pirates should have been bending over backward to sign.
Imagine what the rotation would be if the Pirates had been as aggressive as the Braves were and signed Colon — heck and Dickey, too — on one-year deals.
The rotation would be something like Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon, Bartolo Colon, Chad Kuhl and R.A. Dickey.
That’s a rotation that suddenly looks a lot more competitive and a lot more capable of giving the Pirates a puncher’s chance in the fight for the NL Central Division title and a very strong chance to at least grab a wild card spot.
And with an innings-eater in the middle of it like Colon, it would help protect the bullpen a little bit, especially if Cole can return to his 200-plus inning form of 2015 and Taillon can stay healthy, too.
The fifth starter doesn’t even have to be Dickey. If the Pirates would have gotten Colon, just a pitcher of Dickey’s profile, an inexpensive one-year veteran capable of winning games, would fit as the fifth starter.
They can still fill that role, but they aren’t likely to get a pitcher as good as Colon to fit into their budget and their long-term goals.
An addition such as Colon would have given the Pirates an extra year to figure out which of their seemingly endless bench of Class AAAA pitchers — Steven Brault, Drew Hutchison, Tyler Glasnow, Brandon Cumpton, Nick Kingham, etc. — can actually help them win games consistently at the major league level.
The Pirates cannot go into the season with Taillon, Cole, Kuhl and two from this group as their rotation; that will be a recipe for disaster.
The Pirates need to be more aggressive and creative and not wait until later to see who is available or what is left on the market if they are truly interested in becoming a playoff team again.
They missed on Colon, and there is no excuse for it, because he could have helped them win a lot of games.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.