The World Series is over, and the Cubs are the champs. Though it didn’t involve the local team, there was a lot that happened this postseason that the local team can learn from. In fact, I would argue the World Series was a dose of good news and bad news for the Pirates, and though there was reason for hope for Pirates fans, there was also doom and gloom.
People always complain that the media is too negative and always searches for reasons to criticize, so in the spirit of breaking that stereotype, I’ll start with the positives for the Pirates.
The Cleveland Indians are not a big-market team, they are a smaller-market team, and their payroll was not among the top 20 in baseball. Yet, they were two runs away from the winning the World Series. So, there is indeed hope for the budget-conscious Pirates. When you look at how the Indians got this far, it’s a plan that looks similar to the one Neal Huntington has used to find some degree of success.
The Indians are built on great starting pitching and a strong bullpen, much like Huntington has tried to do with the Pirates. They also have enough power but aren’t built around hitting homers (10th in the American League in homers). Instead, they’re built around putting the ball in play and being able to score runs by playing small ball (fourth in the AL in batting average, on-base percentage and on-base plus slugging). They were built with a great combination of winning — yet inexpensive — veteran acquisitions and excellent young, homegrown talent. In fact, they had only two players — Coco Crisp ($11 million) and Mike Napoli ($16 million) — who made more than $10 million a year.
That is certainly a formula the Pirates can follow, and when you compare payrolls the Indians only spent about $9 million more, which is really not that much at all. The Pirates (i.e. Bob Nutting) need to understand that trying to operate on a $105 million budget is going to get tougher and tougher as the years go on. A reasonable budget for the Pirates — given what they spend already — should be about $115 million, which is what the Indians spent.
The other thing the Indians did that the Pirates have not done is understand that they had a good group assembled and, because of their budget constraints, that they had a limited window to win. Rather than worry about 2022 and beyond, they unloaded four really good prospects to bring in the missing piece to their bullpen — Andrew Miller. That put them over the top, especially in the playoffs.
Read More
So, the hope for the Pirates out of this World Series, and even last year’s World Series, is that they have a model in the Indians and the Royals. That’s assuming they stretch themselves a little bit more financially and be more willing to play for now.
That’s the good news.
The bad news is that the Cubs, who are the Pirates’ National League Central Division rivals, are really, really good, and they aren’t going anywhere any time soon. We kind of knew that, but winning this title while, at times, looking awfully inexperienced and with their manager not exactly having a stellar World Series speaks volumes of their talent.
Kris Bryant may be the best player in baseball right now. Forget about the homers, he is becoming a really tough out. He’s one of the best base-runners already and gets better defensively seemingly every week. Then you have Anthony Rizzo, who is an excellent hitter, Ben Zobrist, who did exactly what he was brought to Chicago to do and Dexter Fowler, who is an excellent lead-off man. And of course you have superstar youngsters Willson Contreras, Javier Baez and Addison Russell. All three looked a lot like rookies throughout the postseason but also had many moments when they showed how talented they are.
Theo Epstein and Co. have done a great job of putting together a team and an organization that is now the envy of the sport. People can say he just threw money at problems, but those people are wrong. Epstein’s genius shows in the overall organizational strength. The Cubs are built using the same philosophies and analysis the Pirates pride themselves on. The difference is Epstein has been aggressive and bold in making moves. He also has more money to spend than Huntington does, so if it feels like the Pirates are now light years behind the Cubs, it’s because they are.
It isn’t just about spending money, though. Epstein is savvy and smart, making the right moves based on what the team — which won 97 games last year, by the way — needed. He knew they needed one more pitcher, so he added John Lackey. He knew they needed veteran bats in their lineup to cut down on strikeouts and mentor the younger players, so he brought in Zobrist and re-signed Fowler. Although Jason Heyward didn’t have a great year, if you listen to the players talk about his impact in terms of his leadership — not to mention his defense, base-running and arm — it’s clear he was the right veteran player for Epstein to sign, too.
Even though the Cubs won the World Series, Epstein isn’t going to rest on his laurels. He will continue to make them better, so the Pirates will be chasing a juggernaut for years to come. And now, the Cubs know how to win. They also may have even arrived a year earlier than they should have, given their youth in certain areas. They have some decisions to make in the offseason, but again, Epstein and Co. will be bold and make the right moves. They will continue to try to strengthen their bullpen.
That doesn’t mean the Pirates can’t beat the Cubs, nor does it mean they can’t catch them at some point. It does mean that the Pirates have a lot of work to do to get back to the point where they have a chance to compete with the Cubs.
The question is, are they willing to do what it takes financially to give themselves a chance? That’s a fair question, and only time will tell us the answer.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.