The chess match between the two managers in the World Series has been fun to watch. Both Joe Maddon and Terry Francona have been bold and brilliant in the use of their pitching staffs.
But please spare me the “These guys are geniuses” and “The way bullpens will be used is changed forever” narratives that are going on. At the end of the day, this is baseball, not rocket science, and it is do-or-die time.
Analytics have changed the way we think about baseball, in many cases for the better. But this is still a game played by humans, and managers don’t look smart unless players execute.
It is nice to dream about a world where pitchers all have similar roles and are used as needed all throughout the season like both managers have done this postseason (and Dodgers manager Dave Roberts did in the NLCS). But it would be a recipe for disaster in the regular season.
On Sunday night, for instance, Maddon used closer Aroldis Chapman to get the final eight outs of the game, and this was seen as some sort of bold, revolutionary strategy.
Desperate times call for desperate measures, and Chapman is by far Maddon’s best pitcher and his best weapon. In a “lose and go home” game, he had no choice but to let Chapman try to finish.
But how long would Chapman last if he was throwing 102 mph and trying to get eight outs and throwing 40-plus pitches multiple times per week?
In Francona’s case, his two best pitchers are his back-end relievers, but he has been without two of his top starters, so he has had to manipulate his pitching staff to navigate through the postseason.
It has worked, and of course it has now led to this movement of analytics guys who have pushed the idea of “bullpenning” — essentially getting rid of roles for pitchers and using your best pitchers as needed — as a new way of handling pitching staffs.
Francona, thankfully, has quieted that crowd a bit and has said there is no way he could use his pitching staff the way that he has this postseason in the regular season because he’d have a bunch of tired and/or ruined arms by September.
He also took it one step further and said if he had all of his pitchers healthy, he wouldn’t be using his bullpen so much because he wouldn’t need to. He is doing what he is doing out of necessity, not because he wants to reinvent the wheel.
Both of these guys are great managers, by the way, and have done a great job of utilizing their resources, but the “genius” stuff is ridiculous and mostly a product of the results-oriented thinking that is so prevalent in modern day sports.
Had Chapman given up a two-run homer in the ninth Sunday night, Maddon would have been crushed for leaving him in too long and letting him go way beyond what he is capable of in terms of pitch count.
Similarly, the reason that Francona has looked like a genius is Corey Kluber, who he has used on short rest a few times this postseason. Kluber has been downright nasty, and Andrew Miller and Cody Allen have been unhittable.
I do think the rigid roles that are set up in bullpens need to change some, and managers need to be a little more creative and willing to use their closers in different spots throughout games depending on the situations.
They have changed some, and some managers are more open minded to it, but anybody that believes you could get away with using pitchers the way Francona, and to a less extent, Maddon, have this postseason during the regular season really doesn’t understand baseball and the daily grind that it is.
It is one thing to use guys a lot in the postseason, when there is no tomorrow and a lot of rest coming in the offseason; it is another thing to overuse them when you have 30 games to play in 31 days in May.
Playoff baseball is different than regular season baseball, so managers and coaches make different, unconventional moves during the playoffs and do so because there is no tomorrow. That desperation is what makes the postseason so much fun to watch.
It isn’t the same as the regular season, and thus there is no reason to continue to ask, “Why don’t managers do these things in the regular season” because most of them work in the short term but for a variety of reasons would be a disaster in the long term.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.