It probably isn’t hyperbole to suggest that Sunday may be one of the last times we get to see the Tom Brady/Bill Belichick-led Patriots at Heinz Field. Brady’s career is winding down, and Belichick is nearing retirement age, too. And any time the Patriots come to town, it sparks discussions about the legacies of both and the idea that they’re forever tied together. The reasons are obvious: They won four Super Bowls together, appeared in two others and have been to the AFC championship in each of the past five seasons.
As a result of that success, they seem to always be in the conversation as the greatest coach and greatest quarterback in NFL history, not to mention the greatest coach-quarterback combination. I think that’s a mistake. Their legacies should not be intertwined, and their accomplishments should not be viewed in the same light because they are different.
Brady’s legacy is simple and mostly untarnished — despite some under-inflated footballs he threw against the Colts in the AFC title game two years ago. He is one of the three greatest quarterbacks ever.
I personally would rank them in this order: Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, John Elway, Joe Montana, but there are lots of arguments to put Brady or Montana first. I’m not sure any serious list would have a top five that didn’t include those four. Regardless of how you rank them, Brady is clearly right there with the others, if not at the top.
Belichick’s legacy, though, is far more complicated and far tougher to gauge. The stench of several cheating scandals, the fact that he’s never really won anything without Brady and his conveniently forgotten stint in Cleveland will forever tarnish his accomplishments.
I’m not saying he isn’t a good coach. He may even be a great coach, but it’s hard for me to reconcile his on-field success without at least considering some of the other factors that have led to it.
Read More
Spygate, Deflategate, mysterious questions about bugs in locker rooms — Belichick’s teams always are looking for an edge. So, even though I don’t believe spying or deflating footballs really was a major factor in their wins, they must have been some factor and provide some edge. Otherwise, why do them?
Cheating has to be a part of Belichick’s legacy. It’s the environment he created, and while he and his apologists can cry that it’s unfair, it’s reality and it’s his own fault. The second part of Belichick’s legacy is that he coached seven seasons without Brady as his starting quarterback and made the playoffs once.
That’s not a misprint. In seven seasons without Brady (1991-95 with the Browns, 2000 and 2008 with Patriots), he has a record of 52-60 and has one playoff appearance — and he lost in the divisional round.
In Cleveland, he had Bernie Kosar and Vinny Testaverde, who aren’t Montana and Dan Marino, but they weren’t chopped liver, either. In fact, compared to the quarterbacks the Browns have had since they returned from their hiatus in the late 1990s, those two are Marino and Montana.
He was in Cleveland five seasons and finished with a winning record once — and they were worse when he left than when he got there. That is hardly the work of a genius.
Even his first year at New England — 2000 — he inherited Drew Bledsoe and went 5-11. Although Bledsoe wasn’t great that year, it wasn’t like he inherited a team with Brandon Weeden as the best quarterback on the roster.
A lot of coaches need a great quarterback to win, so why does it get held against Belichick? A lot of coaches have had at least some level of success with quarterbacks who aren’t all timers, and a lot of coaches who have had success have done so with multiple quarterbacks.
Chuck Noll wasn’t a world beater after Terry Bradshaw retired, but in 1984 he got to the AFC championship with Mark Malone as his starter, and he got to the second round in 1989 with Bubby Brister.
Joe Gibbs won three Super Bowls with three different starting quarterbacks, Bill Parcells had success everywhere he went with different quarterbacks — including a Super Bowl with Jeff Hostetler — and Tony Dungy in Tampa had success with guys like Shaun King.
In other words, Belichick’s “genius” and superior Xs and Os are not so genius when he doesn’t have Brady playing quarterback for him. Belichick is obviously a great coach in many ways. He has won a lot of games and Super Bowls, and his teams seem to always play with discipline and an edge. But spare me the greatest of all time stuff when you talk about him because there are far too many questions about cheating and far too much evidence that his record is a product of having Brady to put him in that category.
Brady is legitimately an all-timer, maybe the best quarterback of all time. But I’m not ready to put Belichick in that class and probably never will unless he coaches 10 years beyond Brady and proves he can win consistently without him.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.