Ben Roethlisberger is a great quarterback. He also says silly things that seem to cause a stir even though most of the time it’s just hot air.
Notice I used the word “silly” and not “dumb” to describe these things because I don’t think for one second Roethlisberger doesn’t know exactly what he is saying at all times and exactly what kind of reaction he will get. Tuesday nights on 93.7 The Fan, I replay the Ben Roethlisberger show, and almost every week I build an entire segment dissecting something he said that is over the top, not exactly intellectually honest or just outright nonsense. I don’t think he’s malicious. I just think he likes to throw stuff out there and knows that some of his mouthpieces in the local media will run with it and/or it will lead to some silly controversy. Last year, for instance, there was the “concussion” controversy, in which he said one thing and Mike Tomlin said something else, which was eerily similar to the “broken toes” controversy when Bill Cowher was coach.
Roethlisberger’s latest example came Tuesday during his radio show when he said blamed, at least in part, the Steelers’ laundry list of injuries on their physical training camp. Roethlisberger added a not-so-subtle hint for Mike Tomlin that “we need to take care of our guys.”
Naturally, this has turned into a story and even gained some traction nationally. I’m sure there will be some discussion sparked about whether physical practices are necessary in this day and age. My first reaction is to ask that if physical training camps are really the issue, how in the world did any team in the 1970s and ’80s survive and have enough players to finish the season? Training camps back then were far more physical then than they are now. As the Post-Gazette’s Ed Bouchette noted in that story linked above, the NFL made rules changes in 2011 to limit the number of practices in pads and how physical teams can be. The league, essentially, makes sure there is almost no hitting during the season.
It’s always fun to listen to former players comment on modern training camps and practices. They all laugh and say camps now basically are a picnic compared to what they went through. That doesn’t mean training camp is easy, but most former players I’ve talked to tell tales about what they went through and claim training camps now are actually easier than their in-season practices used to be. I believe them because I covered Pitt football when Dave Wannstedt was the coach, and I heard some of his stories about how tough training camps were when he coached with the Cowboys and Bears.
I don’t long for the “good old days” when “men were men.” A lot of the changes to the way football is practiced is good. But I also know some coaches, like Stanford’s David Shaw, for instance, have been critics of the movement to limit the full-contact blocking and tackling at practices. Shaw actually takes the opposite approach of the movement away from full-contact practices, as he has said that the only way to learn how to block and tackle properly — and thus avoid injury — is to practice in a controlled environment with coaches who can teach fundamentals and technique. There is some merit to that, but as someone who has covered football a long time and as someone who has a son that plays at a pretty high level, I can tell you this: The way football practices are conducted now — with a happy medium between the Junction Boys and a day at the spa — is probably the way to go.
Read More
The cumulative effect of getting hit every day, sometimes two or three sessions per day (when they used have two-a-days and three-a-days) is too much on a human body, and I’m glad the rules have changed to try to protect the athletes. But like Shaw said, it is important for guys to learn how to tackle properly and to learn how to prevent injuries when they fall or get hit. So, you can’t completely take tackling and blocking out of practices.
That brings me back to Roethlisberger’s statements about the Steelers’ injuries. I think his theory would hold a lot more water if we weren’t eight or nine weeks removed from the end of training camp and five weeks into the season. If training camp really was that physical and players were that beat up by it, wouldn’t injuries hit at the end of training camp and during the last few weeks of the preseason?
Just about every one of these injuries we are talking about — and the list is long — happened during a game. Could the wear and tear from a really tough, physical training camp cause guys to get hurt or be more vulnerable to injury? Yes, absolutely, and I think Tomlin learned this lesson his first year, when he tried to lay down the law and run a physical camp and had an immediate and strong pushback from the players. He has since modified his ways. Though the Steelers remain a little more physical at training camp than a lot of other teams, they are nowhere close to what they used to be.
Perhaps Roethlisberger is just being a team leader and getting a message to Tomlin that some of his teammates believe they got beat up at training camp, but I don’t think that’s the case. I think this was just Ben being Ben and stirring the pot, mostly because he knows he can.
Tomlin’s training camp isn’t too hard or too physical. The game is just brutal, and injuries are a part of it. Sometimes a team gets hit harder than others for no other reason than dumb luck.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.