On Saturday, I sat at Heinz Field and watched Georgia Tech’s Paul Johnson make an overly aggressive decision to go for it on fourth-and-short in the fourth quarter tied with Pitt.
It didn’t work out, but it wasn’t a necessary risk to take because the score was tied and there were less than two minutes to play. A punt would have meant the Panthers would have had to go a long way to set up a winning field goal and probably would have resulted in overtime. Johnson went for it, the Yellow Jackets didn’t make it, and they lost. Despite that, even Georgia Tech fans who hated that decision at least walked away from the game saying Johnson played to win.
Sunday, I again sat at Heinz Field and watched as another head coach — the Jets’ Todd Bowles — decided to punt the ball not once, but twice, in the fourth quarter on fourth-and-short, which was amazingly bad on his part. Unlike Johnson, Bowles needed to go for it at least in one of those two situations, if not both, as his team was trailing the Steelers by 11.
Asking why he would punt both times would be great questions. My only answer is that he didn’t really want to win the game. Although I thought Johnson’s decision Saturday was dumb, too, I could at least respect a guy — regardless of outcome — who wasn’t afraid to try to win.
The Steelers predictably cashed in on the second of Bowles’ conservative decisions with a long touchdown drive that consumed most of what was left on the clock while the Jets offense stood on the sidelines an watched its team lose, 31-13.
Unlike Georgia Tech fans — some of whom said they loved Johnson’s aggressiveness when I talked to them after the game — Jets fans walked out of the stadium wondering if Bowles actually understands what he is doing and if he actually was trying to win.
Read More
That’s not just a guess by me, by the way. In this world of social media, the disdain of fans is easily detected, as this column by Mike DeCourcy of the Sporting News so neatly points out. In case you don’t feel like reading DeCourcy’s piece, the Cliff Notes version is that Jets fans believe Bowles quit with his decisions to punt late. Judging by the grilling Bowles got after the game by the New York media, I’m going to go out on a limb and say those reporters thought it was bad coaching, too.
It has become clear to me over the years that fans — and media — will live with a coach who makes aggressive decisions from time to time, even when they don’t work out, but coaches who always play it safe usually get crushed and end up getting fired. That’s especially true in this era of pass-happy offenses and high scoring. It’s becoming even more clear to me that coaches who are slaves to the old NFL script, which is to always err on the side of caution, may not be employed very long because they won’t win enough.
Mike Tomlin made an idiotic decision to try for a fake field goal earlier in the game — why have punter/holder Jordan Berry try to pick up 2 yards when you have an offense as loaded with skill players as the Steelers? — and it blew up in his face. It failed miserably, but at least people can say Tomlin was playing to win the game. His players feed off of that. Ben Roethlisberger loves that the Steelers take shots, and I think that’s why Tomlin has had a lot of success.
Does that mean it is always smart to throw caution to the wind? Absolutely not, and the road to coaching hell is paved with lots of guys who don’t understand that caution and conservative play-calling in moderation are good things. There are times to be more aggressive and take chances, and in this case, on this day, Bowles blew it. Not once, but twice.
I’m willing to give Bowles the benefit of the doubt on the first decision to punt, even though it was only about 2 feet for the Jets to get the first down. With 13 minutes left, there was still some time for the Jets to get a couple of stops and score twice. I would have gone for it, and most people I talked to in the press box agreed, but nobody was ready to kill Bowles for this decision because most NFL coaches would have punted there. There was enough time left to justify it.
But with 7:36 to play, the Jets faced a fourth-and-2 at their own 46 and still trailed by 11, and yet Bowles decided to punt again. That was an awful decision, and it seemed 100 percent contrary to the Jets mantra after the game that their backs are against the wall. Really, if your back was against the wall, why did your coach act with zero sense of urgency, and why did he choose not to have faith in his offense in key situations to get a yard or two?
Bowles’ answer was predictable, that there was enough time on the clock and that the Jets could pin the Steelers in their own territory and force a three-and-out.
I’m so tired of this answer from NFL coaches who just can’t help themselves. You had the ball on the 46 with 7:36 to play, and you needed two scores. What was really to be gained in punting there? The Steelers’ first three plays after the punt took almost three minutes off the clock, so even if the Jets had gotten a stop on third down, they would have taken over somewhere around their 40. So, the Jets would have had to go six more yards than the previous possession to score, and instead of having seven minutes to score twice, they now would have had only four. Oh, by the way, they only had two timeouts left because Bowles decided to blow one challenging the spot of the ball on the third down right before the first punt with 13:08 to play — even though the replay showed clearly the spot was correct.
Jets quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick took the high road when he was asked about the decisions and said that he should have made more plays to avoid that situation and repeated several times that the team has “faith in the coaches” to make the right decisions. Wide receiver Quincy Enunwa said the same thing, as did Brandon Marshall. All three acknowledged that although, as offensive players, they always think they can go for it and get the first down, they believe Bowles knows what is best.
I understand that. Players shouldn’t take on their coach publicly, and while at the end of the day it’s about execution and players making plays, coaches need to give their guys a chance to win games.
Johnson, the Georgia Tech coach, gave his team a chance to win, and it just didn’t make a play — or you could say Pitt’s defense did make a play. Bowles, however, didn’t even give the Jets a chance to make a play, and that’s a big reason they weren’t able to come from behind to upset the Steelers.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.