Orioles manager Buck Showalter has had a great career, but his decision to leave one of the best pitchers in baseball sitting in the bullpen in an 11-inning loss to Toronto in the wild card game will haunt him forever. And it should, because it’s inexcusable.

In case you missed it Tuesday night, Showalter used six relievers and none of them was his ace closer, Zach Britton. Not in the bottom of the ninth with the score tied, 2-2, and Blue Jays on first and second with no outs, and not in the bottom of the 11th with Blue Jays on first and third and one out.

The Orioles got out of the first jam because Darren O’Day forced Blue Jays catcher Russell Martin to ground into a 5-4-3 double play. But in the 11th, Edwin Encarnacion hit a 3-run walk-off homer off Orioles reliever Ubaldo Jimenez, and Britton never made it out of the bullpen.

Showalter explained after the game that Britton was healthy and available, but Showalter had a lot of faith in the other guys. That makes no sense. This was a one-and-done playoff that went extra innings, and Showalter left his best pitcher on the bench.

Advertise with us

There are some who assumed Showalter was being an old-school manager and saving Britton for if/when the Orioles — the road team — secured a lead, though Showalter never said as much. That sparked the discussion about old-school managers needing to change their ways and stop being prisoners to the conventional use of pitching staffs and bullpens. It’s an interesting discussion, and it took place all over social media and on national radio/TV.

The supposedly new school of thought is to use the closer, theoretically each team’s best pitcher, in whatever situation he is needed most, not just in the ninth inning. The thinking is that if there’s a one-run game and a pitcher gets into a jam, why not bring the closer in to clean up the mess?

Ideas about using closers in tied extra-inning games on the road has changed as well. MLB.com Cardinals reporter Jen Langosh wrote about manager Mike Matheny’s complete change on this issue. He never brought in his closer into tied games on the road until this year. His reasoning was exactly what we’re talking about with Showalter Tuesday night.

“You say, OK, we have our best pitcher. … And do we get to that next inning if we don’t pitch him in that inning?” Matheny said. “You have, statistically, your best arm down there ready to go and their best part of the lineup. I think there are a lot of arguments, at least that I have in my own mind, that lead me toward giving [the closer] a chance to get us through that. When the game ends and you still have him sitting down there and he could have pitched, those are things you look back and learn from.”

Showalter escaped the ninth, but at least in that situation he had one of his other top relievers, O’Day, a strikeout guy who is also good at inducing ground balls, so it wasn’t like Showalter’s faith was unfounded. The 11th, however, was mind-boggling. Once the Blue Jays got two men on, Showalter really had only two choices, and he went with option 3.

Advertise with us

Choice 1: Bring in Britton and try to get out of the inning with your best pitcher on the mound. Then bring him back for the 12th, hoping you score a run in the top of the 12th. This is what I would have done, and most people who watchec and commented about it agreed.

Choice 2: Walk Encarnacion to load the bases and have Jimenez pitch to Jose Bautista. That doesn’t sound very smart, until you look at the numbers and see that Bautista is 3 for 38 lifetime against Jimenez.

Showalter did neither, and he will spend the offseason trying to justify his decision-making process.

There’s no guarantee the Orioles would have won had Britton pitched. Maybe he gets out of the 11th, pitches the 12th and there are very few good options to relieve him for the 13th. But that’s the point: You can’t worry about what you will do in the 13th inning in a one-and-done game. You have to worry about getting to the 13th.

Showalter used six relievers, and he never put his best pitcher on the mound. That makes no sense.

Advertise with us

The back cover of a book I’m reading that challenges a lot of baseball conventions, “Ahead of the Curve” by MLB analyst Brian Kenny, has a lot of quotes from people around baseball endorsing the book. One of them is — you guessed it — Buck Showalter.

These kinds of baseball discussions are fascinating to me, especially because the conventional thinking in baseball is changing so much due to analytics and the onslaught of sabermetrics. They’re always are up for debate, and I’m up for a good debate. So, I’d like to get your thoughts on the use of a closer in these situations and whether Showalter deserves all the criticism he is getting. You can comment below or send comments to me on Twitter (@paulzeise) or email (pzeise@post-gazette.com).