The Pirates ability to sign Ivan Nova is not as simple as many observers would like it to be, and that's mostly because it takes two to tango.
His price tag continues to rise every time he takes the mound, and considering the free agent market for pitching is very thin, he probably will be overvalued and overpaid.
To understand where I am coming from, first take a look at the market and see who is available and you can do that in this article by Jon Heyman. He lists Nova as the 11th best overall free agent available, but he is the second starting pitcher on the list behind the Dodgers’ Rich Hill.
That in itself speaks volumes about the market as Hill spent six years in the wilderness and signed a minor league deal last August with the Red Sox in order to try and restart his career.
Hill has been good this year (he signed with the A's in the offseason and was traded to the Dodgers in August) but the fact that Heyman has him projected to be the top pitcher on the market and likely to get a 3-year deal in the neighborhood of $50 million means the market is completely out of whack.
What does that mean for Nova? Teams are going to overpay. Heyman projects him to get a 3-year deal in the neighborhood of $42 million, and that likely is out of the Pirates’ realistic neighborhood. They had to stretch to give Francisco Liriano three years and $39 million, and they might be gun shy to do something similar for Nova, who doesn't have the track record Liriano did when they gave him that extension.
Here is the other thing: Heyman is one of the most respected writers in the country. He has forgotten more about baseball than most people will ever know; he is dialed in with agents and front office people, and he has an excellent feel for the game, so his projections are educated guesses. But I'd be willing to bet because the market is so thin for pitching that Nova will get more than three years and maybe even more than $14 million per year, based on what pitchers earned last year in a market that had more available talent.
Here is a list of the top 50 free agents from last season and then compare the player’s career numbers to Nova's. It gives you a pretty good picture of where he fits.
Take a look at what they ended up with:
Mike Leake got 5-years, $80 million and he was only one year younger than Nova (29) is and if you compare their career numbers, I'm not sure Leake is better.
Jeff Samardzija got 5-years, $90 million.
Scott Kazmir got 3-years, $48 million.
Ian Kennedy got 5-years, $70 million.
All of those guys are similar in age to Nova and, with the exception of Kazmir, all are righties. It’s likely Nova ends up with that kind of payday.
That is the cost of doing business in Major League Baseball, and the Pirates need to have a discussion about that. If the Pirates have a limited budget, they cannot compete in some of these bidding wars and overpay for players or, worse, give them too many years.
We saw how the Jason Kendall contract (six years, $60 million) hamstrung the Pirates in the latter years of the contract. That's why I don't see the Pirates offering a fourth contract year, unless it’s a club option. And it seems unlikely Nova would accept a contract without a fourth year guaranteed.
I think the best course of action, as I have said in the past, is for the Pirates to trade for a veteran pitcher. Signing Nova -— though I think the Pirates should be aggressive and offer a three-year deal in the $12.5 million to $14 million per year range -— is unlikely.
If, though, the price or years rise, I wouldn't blame the Pirates for being cautious and passing on a deal.
The Pirates can't make bad decisions with their money, they can't overcome big mistakes, I get that.
But they also can't compete with the Cubs and Cardinals if they aren't willing to sign players they desperately need at close to market value.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.