Gerrit Cole was shut down for the season Tuesday, and that’s not good news for the Pirates, especially if there’s something more going on than soreness.

Hopefully it is just that — a scare — and some inflammation and Cole, with an offseason of rest and rehab, will be good as new for next season. Even if it is just a scare, it’s the latest example of the Pirates having a hard time keeping their young (or younger) arms healthy.

The injury further underscores how difficult it is to build an entire staff of young prospects and why the Pirates, though admirable for their ability to draft and develop young pitchers, would be smart to sign at least one veteran pitcher, if not two, for next season.

The plan for the Pirates is to build an organization on pitching, and Neal Huntington has done an incredible job at filling the minors. But, as we have seen in the past two years, especially, keeping all of those arms healthy is really almost impossible.

Advertise with us

Cole is just the latest example (though he is now moving out of the “young arm” category), but Jameson Taillon, Brandon Cumpton, Nick Kingham and Tyler Glasnow all have had issues, and Chad Kuhl’s starts have been skipped too. The health of pitchers is an inexact science to begin with, but that’s why I have always maintained the Pirates may be putting too many eggs in the homegrown pitching basket. For this plan to work out, the Pirates will need all of these guys to stay healthy over the next few seasons, and I’ve seen no evidence that any is capable of staying healthy over the course of a long season.

Take Cole, for instance. This was his fourth season, and only once has he gone more than 150 innings. Sure, in 2013, he didn’t get called up until June, but in 2014 and this year he had stints on the disabled list. That’s not a good thing for such a young pitcher. That doesn’t mean he isn’t durable or is injury prone, but it’s not irrelevant, either.

If the Pirates are going to go into next season with Cole, Taillon, Glasnow, Kuhl all in their starting rotation, it’s a mistake. It’s also a mistake to continue to hoard pitching prospects thinking they will someday be part of the rotation. Way too much can happen to pitchers, and while you want to hold on to top guys such as Taillon and Cole, some of the others could have been used over the past few years in deals to make the major league team better.

The Pirates have a smart plan and are built for the long haul with a lot of young players locked up for a long time. They have depth in the minors. They don’t have any awful contracts hampering them over the next few years. They’re good at filling in holes with veterans that don’t cost a lot of money and seem to fit in. But that becomes a house of cards if all of these pitching prospects aren’t able to grow up quickly and stay healthy because, again, the organization has stated it will be built on pitching.

That’s a large gamble, and the Pirates would be smart to take a page from the Cubs organization and look to build the rotation and depth with a combination of homegrown pitchers and veterans.

For Cole’s sake, I hope his injury is just a scare, but there have been too many scares — or in the case of Taillon, Kingham and Cumpton, far more than scares — to feel comfortable about the future of the rotation unless the Pirates commit to adding some veterans along the way.