So, let me get this straight.

The Pitt-Penn State game is supposedly the game both sides have been waiting for since the series ended in 2000, but one side isn’t talking about it at all, and the other side says it’s not a rivalry. The presidents of both schools are issuing statements asking fans to be civil and nice to each other.

Does that mean Pitt fans who wear shirts saying “directions to Penn State: East until you smell it, North until you step in it” will be stopped at the door and asked to change, or does that slip under the “all in good fun” clause of this civility pact?

Remind me again why these teams were so hell-bent on playing this game.

Advertise with us

There is more hype and excitement leading up to a typical Pitt ACC game or a typical Penn State Big Ten game than there has been leading up to this. Most of the work in silencing the hype has been done by the schools and coaches, and they’re the ones who should be fueling it.

I just don’t get it. Don’t tell us it’s a big game between heated rivals and then try to play it down, refuse to talk about it and sick the PC police on it. You’re undermining everything that makes a great rivalry great.

Either way, despite the best attempts of both sides to downplay this game, it’s significant for both teams, and both coaches have a lot on the line.

Yeah, I know, there isn’t a conference championship at stake, and as I wrote earlier this week, I don’t believe there is a recruiting windfall waiting on the winner. But that doesn’t mean that the coaches and programs don’t have a lot to lose in this one.

Start with James Franklin, who has a lot of similarities to Todd Graham in his self-promotion and chest pounding about his program. That’s why he ruffles so many feathers among opposing fans. But it isn’t just opposing fans whose feathers have been ruffled. Penn State’s own fans are a little skeptical of the direction of the program because Franklin’s first two years have been extremely unspectacular and his handling of Christian Hackenberg was a disaster.

Advertise with us

Franklin was 14-12 in his first two seasons and is 6-10 in Big Ten games, so this is the year the program is expected to take a step forward. It’s not a shock he’s trying so hard to play down this game. He understands just how badly he needs to win this game to maintain his credibility.

He came to Penn State proclaiming they would dominate the state. If they lose to Pitt Saturday, that will be two consecutive losses against in-state foes — last year, the Nittany Lions got pounded by Temple.

Penn State can avenge its loss to the Owls next week, but if it loses to Pitt, that would be a hollow victory. If this season ends with another 7-6 record with the Nittany Lions not being in the hunt for a Big Ten title, Franklin’s seat will start to get awfully warm.

You can’t beat your chest about being the premier program in the state and lose to teams in your own state in back-to-back years.

A win Saturday doesn’t mean that Franklin is out of the woods with some of his doubters, but it certainly would ease some of the pressure because in the minds of many Penn Staters a loss to Pitt is a loss to an inferior program.

Advertise with us

And that’s precisely why Pat Narduzzi is under just as much pressure to win — for 16 years since they last played (and Pitt won 12-0), Pitt coaches and fans have been beating the drum that they don’t have to take a backseat to their brethren to the East.

There have been years when Pitt was clearly better than Penn State since then, but they have always had to fight that “we’re the little brother” inferiority complex regardless of what happened on the field.

Penn State has more money than Pitt, has a much larger fan base and because it is the large centrally located state university, it casts a shadow over everyone else in the state.

This perception that Penn State is superior to Pitt has burned a lot of people over in Oakland and in their fan base for a long, long time, and that’s why they’ve pointed to this game for so long since it was announced.

But here is the thing: That’s putting a lot of eggs in one basket and a lot of importance on one game, and there is definitely a “be careful what you wish for” quality to this game for Pitt.

Advertise with us

This is definitely a chance to prove that Pitt doesn’t have to take a backseat to Penn State; it is also a chance to prove that Penn State is still the one Pitt is chasing.

And given that this Penn State team appears to be headed for another middling finish in the Big Ten, a loss to them hurts even more because the message would then become “even a mediocre Penn State team beats Pitt.”

Narduzzi has worked hard to build the program in just a short time. He has established credibility with an improbable 8-5 season last year, and he has endeared himself to the Pitt fan base with his blue collar approach and his ability to recruit.

All of that is a good start, but if he loses this one Saturday, it is a setback for him as there are a number of people in this fan base who seem to think this one game is far more important than the other 11 combined.

I can’t prove it, but I bet there is a percentage of Pitt fans larger than it should be who, if given the choice would rather go 1-11 with a win over Penn State than 11-1 with the one loss being to Penn State. That’s just nutty to me.

Advertise with us

That’s the little brother syndrome coming out, by the way, and it’s putting way too much stock in one non-conference game. But Pitt fans and football coaches want to shed that little brother perception, and this is there shot to do it.

So again, both sides can try to play it down, one side can refuse to talk about it and both presidents and athletic directors can try and silence all of the chatter between the fan bases. But that doesn’t change the fact that both sides — and coaches — have a lot more to lose in this one than they have to win.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com