A couple of days ago, after the Brewers completed a sweep of the Pirates, Andrew McCutchen, to paraphrase, said it isn’t over until the fat lady sings with respect to his team’s fleeting playoff chances.
After the Pirates blew a 6-5 lead to the Cardinals Tuesday by giving up three home runs in the ninth inning, falling 5½ games behind for the second wild card, the fat lady might not be singing yet, but her voice is certainly warmed up and she is headed for the stage.
Nobody should be surprised by this — not even a little bit. This is what the Pirates paid for and wanted. This was always supposed to be a bridge year.
Nobody should be surprised this team is likely headed for about 82 wins (at this point, that may be even too high) and will miss the playoffs for the first time since 2012. Nobody should be surprised they will finish about 20 games behind the Cubs, who they were ahead of last season, in their own division.
The Pirates simply are getting what they deserve, and there is no way to argue otherwise.
Every move they made since the end of last season — a 98-win campaign, by the way — has been with the payroll in mind. Signing guys like John Jaso, Juan Nicasio or Ryan Vogelsong was done as a bandage for this year’s team and nothing more.
They didn’t sign Neil Walker last year. Instead, they traded him, mostly to save $10-11 million.
They didn’t sign Pedro Alvarez. They designated him for assignment, mostly because they overvalued defense and undervalued his ability to hit the ball out of the park.
Part of the Pirates’ issues is that some of their best players — McCutchen, Francisco Liriano, Gerrit Cole, Tony Watson, Jung Ho Kang — have not had great seasons, but some of that is mitigated by guys like David Freese, Matt Joyce and Sean Rodriguez producing far more than they could have hoped.
The larger issue is that the Pirates’ front office took a 98-win team, and instead of building on it and making it better to challenge the Cubs, decided to tear it apart and make it worse — much worse, to be honest.
You aren’t serious about contending for a World Series when you start the season with three-fifths of your rotation being journeymen, but that’s precisely what they had in Jon Niese, Jeff Locke and Vogelsong/Nicasio. Rather than using some of their financial flexibility to address first base, they signed a journeyman with no power and marginal speed who has never played the position before in Jaso. Then, they let relievers Antonio Bastardo, Joakim Soria and Joe Blanton move on and tried to replace them with A.J. Schugel, Cory Luebke, Kyle Lobstein, Rob Scahill and the like.
In just a few months, the Pirates went from a 98-win team that had one of the best rotations and bullpens in baseball, to a team that had a rotation with more questions than answers, a shaky bullpen and a shocking lack of power.
Neal Huntington had earned the benefit of the doubt with the way he had manipulated the payroll and found diamonds in the rough and put the team in position to make the playoffs in each of the past four years (though it fell short in 2012) and so people were willing to give it to him and see how it played out. Hopefully this is a lesson learned. You can only pull a rabbit out of a hat so many times before the optical illusion no longer fools everyone. While you look like a genius when one or two of your reclamation projects turns into something, constantly relying on those guys to come through is not a long-term strategy for winning at a high level.
The Pirates gambled that their reliance on analytics would overcome their lack of talent in the rotation.
They lost.
They also told us their lack of power was not an issue, that they could overcome it with high on base percentage and a lineup full of contact hitters.
They were wrong.
They asked us to believe that a new delivery would transform Locke and Vogelsong into different pitchers and that Niese’s ability to induce ground balls would play well in PNC Park and that Ray Searage was a magic man who could fix every pitcher’s problem.
None of that played out the way they imagined, and a lot of it blew up in their faces.
That doesn’t even address the trading deadline moves in which the Pirates dumped salary (and traded prospects to do so) and got rid of their All-Star closer for two younger arms, even though they were in the thick of the wild-card race.
This was not a good season for Huntington and company — not on the field, not off the field and not in the standings — but that doesn’t mean they can’t rectify it in this upcoming offseason.
But again, they must learn from the mistakes of last offseason and understand that you get what you pay for and you can’t catch teams like the Cubs and Nationals unless you are willing to stretch a little bit financially from time to time in order to solidify the roster.
The Pirates have a good core of players coming back again next year, but they need help in the offseason, or next year will be a repeat of this year. That’s not a good thing, considering where this year is headed.
A bargain-basement rotation of Cole and the four kids (pick four of Jameson Taillon, Chad Kuhl, Nick Kingham, Tyler Glasnow, Brandon Cumpton, Drew Hutchison and Steven Brault) is not going to be good enough to seriously contend in a division with the Cubs and Cardinals.
The Pirates need to go out and find a veteran pitcher to plug into the rotation — and not one that is coming off somebody’s scrap heap and is in need of Searage’s magic touch — in order to solidify their rotation, and they need to stabilize their bullpen. That might cost a few bucks.
There is certainly enough talent already in place for next year that this team doesn’t need dramatic overhauls or even an overhaul at all. But there some things that need to be done to give it a chance to contend, and they all cost money.
The Pirates weren’t willing to stretch their payroll to make moves last offseason, and it cost them dearly. They need to be willing to do that this offseason, or history — the bad kind — will repeat itself and they’ll miss the playoffs for the second year in a row.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.